Prime Oscar vs. Pac Mayweather or Ortiz

[nachorjj]

ODLH UD vs Mayweather
ODLH KO 6 or 8 vs Pacquiao
ODLH KO 1 vs Ortiz

Oscar have problems vs big fighters, vs smalls and booms dont have problems

[MaD RoBoT]

no way he beats Floyd even at his prime

against Pac, hmm maybe 50/50 chance

[jrosales13]

Prime for Prime, doesn't matter what weight-class. Oscar can't **** with Floyd Mayweather jr. Not in Oscar best day and Floyd jr worst day.

Now with Pac it would be interesting. Because, of Oscar size. He is huge compared to Pac. But, talent for talent, P4P, Oscar can't **** with Pac either. However, the size issue might still come to play where it makes it debatable. I will give the edge to Pac. Because, of his stance(southpaw), speed, stamina, and activity. I don't think Oscar would out match him. Pac can be hit with the right often. However, Oscar didn't really have a good right hand. So I give the edge to Pac.

Oscar dominated Victor Ortiz though. No doubt about it.

It's not like Oscar is a scrub. He does get overrated though.

[jrosales13]

ODLH UD vs Mayweather
ODLH KO 6 or 8 vs Pacquiao
ODLH KO 1 vs Ortiz

Oscar have problems vs big fighters, vs smalls and booms dont have problems

Not only was Whitaker a small fighter, he was also washed up and Oscar still had problems.

Even had tougher than expected fight against a shot JCC in the rematch, who was smaller.

And, lets not forget him looking at the time against the smaller Molina.

[MajorKong]

People forget how great Oscar was.

He outworks and decisions a scared Floyd. He destroys Pacquaio with ease because Pacquiao has no defense and Oscar possessed great speed, power and accuracy, and he has a close fight with Ortiz who poses a hard matchup for him stylistically and wins a close decision.

[jrosales13]

People forget how great Oscar was.

He outworks and decisions a scared Floyd. He destroys Pacquaio with ease because Pacquiao has no defense and Oscar possessed great speed, power and accuracy, and he has a close fight with Ortiz who poses a hard matchup for him stylistically and wins a close decision.

[MajorKong]

Just imagine a prime Oscar vs. the shot old Mosley Mayweather fought or Baldomir?

Or imagine prime Oscar vs. Cotto at 145, Margarito at 150, Hatton or David Diaz.

If you want to have a laugh, think about that for a while.

[Check_hooks]

Pac makes him quit on the stool no matter what

Prime Oscar beats Floyd by decision

Oscar beats Ortiz by KO

Cotto and Margarito both destroy prime Oscar

[jrosales13]

Just imagine a prime Oscar vs. the shot old Mosley Mayweather fought or Baldomir?

Or imagine prime Oscar vs. Cotto at 145, Margarito at 150, Hatton or David Diaz.

If you want to have a laugh, think about that for a while.

Triangle Theories

[Guest]

the de la hoya that fought gatti with big floyd as trainer would make it close with floyd
50/50 fight with pac
ko ortiz