Why Cotto is a future Hall-of-Famer

[tredh]

Hell ****ing no!!!!!!!! Cotto belongs in the Hall of Alright Boxers. Cotto never beat an elite prime fighter. Mosley was very good win for Cotto I give him all the credit in the world for that win. Other than that though Cotto didn't do anything special in boxing.

Why would beating any version of Margarito especially this shot one cement Cotto's legacy and assure him a spot in the HOF? That makes no sense at all when considering even without the plaster scandal Margarito was not going to the HOF either!

[Barry Halls]

not yet he isnt...

he could secure his place in the hof by beating margarito come december, and if he could secure chavez before martinez violently takes his belt back, its a given

beating this margarito puts you into the hof?

i guess we should put margarito in it too..... or david haye
not every good fighter you see on tv will end up in the hof.

[The Big Dunn]

Off the top of my head right now Floyd, Manny, Bhop, Roy Jones, JMM, Wlad, Calderon, MAB, Morales, (I'm forgetting some) are active or semi active boxers definitely guaranteed HOF. Is Cotto in that class?

[-PANDA-]

beating this margarito puts you into the hof?

i guess we should put margarito in it too..... or david haye
not every good fighter you see on tv will end up in the hof.

with his record and a redeemed loss, the only flaw on his record would be pacquiao...a bonafide hall of famer

margarito's best win was over cotto and it still has an asterix behind it for most people

explain to me how david haye and tony deserve to be in the hof as much as cotto does...

[tredh]

with his record and a redeemed loss, the only flaw on his record would be pacquiao...a bonafide hall of famer

margarito's best win was over cotto and it still has an asterix behind it for most people

explain to me how david haye and tony deserve to be in the hof as much as cotto does...

Cotto doesn't deserve to be in the HOF is the whole point. Cotto was a good fighter but he is not HOF worthy IMO.

[Barry Halls]

you guys realize theres quite a few awesome fighters not in the hof? people that are for sure greater or as great as cotto?

Camacho, prince naseem, quarry, benn, and thats just the tip of the iceberg.

[Barry Halls]

with his record and a redeemed loss, the only flaw on his record would be pacquiao...a bonafide hall of famer

margarito's best win was over cotto and it still has an asterix behind it for most people

explain to me how david haye and tony deserve to be in the hof as much as cotto does...

and who did cotto beat to put him in the ibhof? Hes got 1 big win in shane mosley who was far from prime.

david haye does not deserve to be in there.. of course not, i was being sarcastic.

Margarito has as good wins as cotto. PRIME Cotto, Martinez, cintron, clottey, vs. mosley, clottey, judah, quintana, foreman.

I like Cotto a lot, but he needs to do more. Beat Martinez or clean the 154 division would be good.

[Larry the boss]

what atg did cotto beat?
what future hof did cotto beat?
why does cotto deserve it over others whos not in it?

cotto needs to do more to justify a HOF spot, and to call him an atg is just so ridiculous.

kind regards,

Cotto-fan

mosley=atg and hof

[Barry Halls]

mosley=atg and hof

yes it has been mentioned

[The_Demon]

I actually think Cotto gets overrated on these boards,i expect Marg too destroy him again