Just saw Mayweather-Castillo I for the First Time...

[IronDanHamza]

when lederman gave the 10th to castillo I laughed.

Lederman gave Round 1 to Chavez in the F.Mayweather-Jesus Chavez fight.

Argubally the most outrageous scoring of a round I have ever seen.

[Champ Is Here]

Hitting arms, and illegal hitting on the break dont mean ****. Yall just dont know **** about judging a fight

[Heeb]

It wasnt a robbery. But the scorecards were a joke.

I can agree with that.

[rayb112]

[QUOTE=Double_L;10726032]I thought Mayweather pulled it out. I know I'm in the minority, but it definitely wasn't a robbery. I even think a draw would've been entirely fair. Here's my scorecard:

ROUND_____1__2__3__4__5__6__7__8__9__10__11__12__TOTAL
Mayweather_10_10_10_10_10_9__9__9__10__9___9___9___114
Castillo_____9__9__9__9__9_10_10__9__9___9__10__10___112


Notes:

- I did think Mayweather won the first 5 rounds by clean, effective punching while avoiding most of Castillo's pressure and shots. If you were to give any of these rounds to Castillo you might give him rd. 3, which was the closest but I still think Mayweather took it.

I have watched both of the fights multiple times...I had Mayweather winning the first by 4 rounds...

114-112 is a stretch...just don't know how you could give Castillo that many rounds...the fight was not as close as the announcers thought it was or the general boxing public which half of them never seen the first first or the second fight let alone...

The second fight was actual a closer fight and someone could make a better argument that Mayweather lost...and the judges had it closer too...it just shows you how people will run with anything they here someone else say and never even watched the fight.

[hugh grant]

Most people thought Floyd lost at the time, but no one knew about his rotar cuff injury. Did he actually have an injury then or is it just rumour?

But the fact that he did have an injury, confirms to people even more so he most likely couldnt win. And are understanding of Floyd losing because of it. But when Pac says he had problems with shin splints and that is why he wasnt as convincing against SSM as he could have been, people laugh.

Bit unfair that.

[BIGBOXINGFAN]

Mayweather won that fight. I don't see what all the fuss is about.

I scored that fight 8 rounds to 4 rounds for Mayweather.

The little shots Castillio landed on the arms were not that effective.

[oc9979]

why did you score round 6 10-9 for Castillo?
If he got a point deducted and he won the round it should of been 9-9. if it is a 10 point system it should have been 10-10

[BIGBOXINGFAN]

Floyd fought that fight with a torn rotator cuff and still won.

Only thing that castillio did was land punches on the arms which are not effective punches.

[Double_L]

why did you score round 6 10-9 for Castillo?
If he got a point deducted and he won the round it should of been 9-9. if it is a 10 point system it should have been 10-10

Whoops that was a typo, good catch. It should've been 9-9, with Castillo winning the round but having a point deduction. Fixed the OP, thanks!

[rambov]

Does not matter. It was close and a rematch was made to settle the score. That's what should happen with all close fights.