Does a Haye win vs THIS Klitschko validate him as a ATG HW?

[STILL_DETOX]

absolutely

[£-4-£]

No.

But it probably secures him a place in the Hall of Fame seeing as though he'd be a two-weight lineal/undisputed champion.

[Pullcounter]

haye has to do a hell of a lot more before you can make him an ATG HW

[extracurRICular]

Too soon to call him an ATG. I don't see anyone calling Buster Douglas an ATG after beating Tyson years later. If he does beat Wlad, he cements himself as the top Heavyweight or at least tied for #1 with Vitali.

Absolutely a great point........I think you just killed my thread ***er.....

ahhaha Green K for you my good sir!!!

[shade darkar]

does it fcuk!!!!! if he beats them both he still isnt an ATG imo.

[theboy_racer]

It just tells us he is a very very good fighter beating a very good but overrated fighter which is what i believe Wlad is, neither are ATG.

[extracurRICular]

It just tells us he is a very very good fighter beating a very good but overrated fighter which is what i believe Wlad is, neither are ATG.

interesting that the overwhelming answer is no..........so what does that say bout the Klits????

[Jimbo16031992]

interesting that the overwhelming answer is no..........so what does that say bout the Klits????

It doesn't really say anyhting aout them, it's just that you have to show dominance to be an ATG.

[Heeb]

No. The rest of his HW resume would still be complete garbage.

[extracurRICular]

It doesn't really say anyhting aout them, it's just that you have to show dominance to be an ATG.

Ok so lets just say he MASSIVELY ko's BOTH the bro's in less than 5 rounds.........then you got him ATG status?