Sergio Martinez vs Andre Dirrel, Who you got?

[Larry the boss]

poll even............

[KnockUTheFukOut]

The problems is that Sergio doesn't like those fights you mentioned at MW, he wants Chavez Jr.

And this argument will not have arised if the Martinez nutriders would not have been calling Pac a coward for not fighting Martinez

He probably wouldn't be calling Manny if Manny didn't move up and win the WBC TITLE THAT HE GAVE UP...you honestly believe Pacquiao would have came after that 154 title if Martinez would have held on to it...*** NO!

[krazyn8tive]

I'll take the fighter that doesn't have it in him to quit...take a guess Lol

[SUPREME.]

I like Martinez but Dirrell would stick him to death.

Dirrell is just a superior fighter in every aspect.

[puga]

He probably wouldn't be calling Manny if Manny didn't move up and win the WBC TITLE THAT HE GAVE UP...you honestly believe Pacquiao would have came after that 154 title if Martinez would have held on to it...*** NO!

pac would've at 150....sergio's belt at 154 aint all that man, just sayin....

[mathed]

Martinez can fight Dirrel, Dirrell has no business now at the Super Six and this will be an awsome feat for Martinez, and after that he could fight Pascal or Dawson an LHW just like he wants Pacquiao to fight him, he's the p4p number 1 it will be easy for him right? Martinez nutriders


Andre Dirrel

6'2 and a 75" reach



vs

Sergio Martinez

5'11 and a 75" reach

Sergio is 5-10...he wins, better boxer

[KingOfBox]

I absolutely admire Sergio. I think he represents what this sport needs. I think he would lose this one though. And I'm not saying it because I think Andre is better... But he is also an amazing talent and he knows how to use his distance and height. I think if Paul was able to give Sergio trouble then so could Andre... GREAT FIGHT!!

[The Gambler1981]

If I had to pick a guy at 168 Martinez should not fight under any circumstances well it would be Andre Dirrell. Not only is Dirrell basically a shitty stylistic opponent for him (and basically anyone for that matter), there is really nothing in it for him because Dirrell has not proven enough for it to be worth the risk.

Just looking at the responses in this thread, why fight a guy that has a a very tough style and gets dogged constantly. It would be a decent fight that I would enjoy but I just don't see the reason in it.

Bute would make a lot more sense to me if Martinez had his heart set on trying 168, more money, more acclaim and while still a very tough fight I can't imagine it being as tough as Dirrell.

[mathed]

If I had to pick a guy at 168 Martinez should not fight under any circumstances well it would be Andre Dirrell. Not only is Dirrell basically a shitty stylistic opponent for him (and basically anyone for that matter), there is really nothing in it for him because Dirrell has not proven enough for it to be worth the risk.

Just looking at the responses in this thread, why fight a guy that has a a very tough style and gets dogged constantly. It would be a decent fight that I would enjoy but I just don't see the reason in it.

Bute would make a lot more sense to me if Martinez had his heart set on trying 168, more money, more acclaim and while still a very tough fight I can't imagine it being as tough as Dirrell.

A Bute fight would be awesome..Bute comes in for the left uppercut and Martinez counters with a right hook...every time.

[paddymcphie]

Sergio is 5-10...he wins, better boxer

I dont care what box-rec lists him as ,he's bigger than 5'10.

I was in Vegas last week and i was standing next to him and im 5'10 1/2 and he was about an inch bigger than me.

5'11 at least.

Fact.