Who has the better WW career Floyd or Manny

[AssasinKing]

Best??? of Top Rank maybe... Real talk if Pac wrecks Shane then he gets mad props... But Margarito after Clottey???? Lame... If this was Floyd...he would have got hate mail. NO ONE has given credit to Floyd for Shane!!!! NOBODY!!!!!!!!!!!! He had just destroyed Margs

Wtf, every1 gave floyd props for beating shane, If any1 hasnt then they are ******......I mean yeah i think it mite have been a LITTLE better if it was all arrange, shane trained and peaked for the fight....but with berto pulling out it messed it up abit...but still, hes a professional and mayweather stood there infront of him and traded all night, even getting hit with 2 huge shots and not going down

who??cotto and clottey??lol

Why would you laugh at the idea of cotto? As if cotto wouldnt give floyd trouble....

Mayweather wouldnt throw enough to put cotto in the state that pac and marg did....so cotto would be pretty deadly throughout the fight....

If anything mayweathers style is best suited for cotto....

Not saying cotto would win, but it would be the hardest fight hes ever had at welter...and id include shane in that

[Larry the boss]

Listen man... Pac has lost to much lesser men than Baldomir AND Judah.. Floyd has lost to NOBODY

true..not only lost..but was ko'd

[ChampBox@PR]

who??cotto and clottey??lol

Yeah thats why Floyd fought Cotto and Clottey, not!!!!!!!

Dude Manny fought and stomped all over the people Floyd ducked or is accused of ducking.

Theres no way in hell Floyd is above Pac in anything but ducking people!!!

[ChampBox@PR]

true..not only lost..but was ko'd

Yeah and that all of the sudden makes Floyd better, LMAO at this dumb****s reaching!!!!

JCC Jr. is the GOAT he is 41-0 LMAO at this morons!!!!

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Floyd's greatest win at WW is merely a PAC tuneup



and instead of hiding in retirement than face Cotto and Margarito, PAC put them on his resume as well

[AssasinKing]

true..not only lost..but was ko'd

Man, you know to much to be stooping to this level, trying to get 1 over another fighter

Its quite embarrassing....

[daggum]

did he win yes or no

does chavez jr 42-0 have a better record than mayweather 41-0? yes or no

[Phenom]

Floyd's greatest win at WW is merely a PAC tuneup



and instead of hiding in retirement than face Cotto and Margarito, PAC put them on his resume as well

PAC put them on his resume handicapped at a catchweight



boxing should really start keeping track and put asterisks next to these career defining catchweight wins

[» HE3R0 «]

Flashback from 2009.

On the ESPN scroll on the bottom of the screen...
Ring Magazine Welterweight Rankings
1. Shane Mosley
2. Miguel Cotto
3. Antonio Margarito
4. Joshua Clottey
5. Manny Pacqiao

seriously...???

IMO

1. Mosley (until Cotto beats him again)
2. Cotto
3. Clottey
4. Berto
5. Collazo or maybe quintana

your opinion

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=258285

Perhaps Mustang's thread from 2009 about the welterweight rankings can help with this question.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

PAC put them on his resume handicapped at a catchweight



boxing should really start keeping track and put asterisks next to these career defining catchweight wins

but he put them on his resume

he asked Cotto to go down one more pound than his last fight and he gave Margarito an extra 3lbs


meanwhile, Floyd hides in retirement...the real asterisk should be put on anything that praises Floyd


* = vagina