Who has the better WW career Floyd or Manny

[AssasinKing]

The difference between them is this

The people pacquiao has faught....would of had way more of a chance of beating mayweather

compared to the people mayweather faught, havin a chance against pac

Imagine baldomir, or judah vs pac......seriously, pac would destroy them

imagine cotto against mayweather..... thats the difference

They are both great, but i personally think pac is great for the reason hes faught the best of the best....and i think mayweather did this early career....but just took his foot of the gas peddle cos he enjoyed his 0 to much....

plus his ego got 2 big

[Stromprophet]

you forgot to take Cotto off Manny's list since it was at a catchweight and all.
so that leaves Manny with clottey and Floyd with Judah and Baldomir and Mosley.


you want to do the math now?

How about admitting this ****** argument is taking place because Floyd fans cannot argue Floyd has the better career so they want to limit it to one division.

[Khalid X]

Clottey>>>Judah
Cotto>>>>Baldomir

unless you wanna factor is ****ty fights like Sharmba Mitchell and Juan Manuel Marquez, I don't see why anyone would even question who has the better resume at 147.

[KingOfBox]

The difference between them is this

The people pacquiao has faught....would of had way more of a chance of beating mayweather

compared to the people mayweather faught, havin a chance against pac

Imagine baldomir, or judah vs pac......seriously, pac would destroy them

imagine cotto against mayweather..... thats the difference

They are both great, but i personally think pac is great for the reason hes faught the best of the best....and i think mayweather did this early career....but just took his foot of the gas peddle cos he enjoyed his 0 to much....

plus his ego got 2 big

Best??? of Top Rank maybe... Real talk if Pac wrecks Shane then he gets mad props... But Margarito after Clottey???? Lame... If this was Floyd...he would have got hate mail. NO ONE has given credit to Floyd for Shane!!!! NOBODY!!!!!!!!!!!! He had just destroyed Margs

[Khalid X]

Oscar hadn't seen WW in 5+ years and was seen chewing ice chips before the fight.... you go figure..

And how its that Manny's fault/problem?

Oscar is a professional and no one asked him to go around eating Kangaroo meat and trying to prove a point by coming in lighter than Manny.

[Larry the boss]

The difference between them is this

The people pacquiao has faught....would of had way more of a chance of beating mayweather

compared to the people mayweather faught, havin a chance against pac

Imagine baldomir, or judah vs pac......seriously, pac would destroy them

imagine cotto against mayweather..... thats the difference

They are both great, but i personally think pac is great for the reason hes faught the best of the best....and i think mayweather did this early career....but just took his foot of the gas peddle cos he enjoyed his 0 to much....

plus his ego got 2 big

who??cotto and clottey??lol

[KingOfBox]

Clottey>>>Judah
Cotto>>>>Baldomir

unless you wanna factor is ****ty fights like Sharmba Mitchell and Juan Manuel Marquez, I don't see why anyone would even question who has the better resume at 147.

Neither Cotto nor Clottey have been lineal champs...

Floyd fought Judah and...Baldomir to cast aside any doubt as to who was lineal.

Point is... When all fights END... They ask... You wanna fight Mayweather??? Not Pacquiao.... MAYWEATHER!!!

[Phenom]

How about admitting this ****** argument is taking place because Floyd fans cannot argue Floyd has the better career so they want to limit it to one division.

out of the divisions both fighters competed 130 135 140 147 154 Floyd has a better career then Manny

[KingOfBox]

The difference between them is this

The people pacquiao has faught....would of had way more of a chance of beating mayweather

compared to the people mayweather faught, havin a chance against pac

Imagine baldomir, or judah vs pac......seriously, pac would destroy them

imagine cotto against mayweather..... thats the difference

They are both great, but i personally think pac is great for the reason hes faught the best of the best....and i think mayweather did this early career....but just took his foot of the gas peddle cos he enjoyed his 0 to much....

plus his ego got 2 big

Listen man... Pac has lost to much lesser men than Baldomir AND Judah.. Floyd has lost to NOBODY and it drives ya'll insane

[Larry the boss]

Clottey>>>Judah
Cotto>>>>Baldomir

unless you wanna factor is ****ty fights like Sharmba Mitchell and Juan Manuel Marquez, I don't see why anyone would even question who has the better resume at 147.

hatton-oscar
shane floyd fought>>shane mannys fighting

baldo-clottey-he beat him