Who has the better WW career Floyd or Manny

[Reloaded]

It still does not change the fact that margarito was more of a threat than Baldomir. In fact, Floyd was petrified on Margarito.

Your full of it mate , a name means nothing on face value " when " you beat that name means everything ,,, when Manny beat Margo a lot of water had gone under the bridge , Margo was a shell from the time your talking off him , coming of being KOed and banned for cheating then he was forced to make a weight that at the time hurt him , *** me its like me saying I can KO Ali , fighters are not at their peak their whole career , Pac just happens to pick the most appropriate time to fight them , just a coincidence aint that right .

Baldy was not weight drained and was at his peak , on the nights of the respective fights Baldy was a lot more of a threat than Margo , your problem is you dont understand weight , but Freddie Roach does , thats why he stands firm on his CWs , or no fight !!

[Saddlebred]

It is a really close call and can be argued either way...really though, *******ville must be a really fun place to live...anybody Pacquiao fights is some "legendary fighter everyone else was ducking" and anybody he didn't fought is "too big" or "not ready." It really demonstrates how naive and new to the sport a large portion of Pacquiao fans are that they believe anything Arum says. The guy is one of the sleaziest people on the planet, but somehow because he is Pacquiao's promoter it must mean he is a "good guy." If it wasn't for Pacquiao's fanbase over the last few years, I would really give him more credit.

All these threads ****ting on every other boxer in history because you want a guy with the same skin color as you to be the best just makes Pacquiao look worse. The same goes for these diehard Mayweather people too. I wasn't even a Mayweather fan until the *******s started showing up and laying into the guy nonstop because they think it makes Pacquiao look better. Now apparently I'm a ***** because I don't agree with all this Manny Pacquiao #1 BEST ALL TIME!!! FLOYD COWARD Chikin scared Manny Pilipino Tsunami knockout floyd run scare!!!! garbage.

[jltsmae]

FLoyd Mayweather Jr....He beat Baldomir when Many WW were not willing to fight Baldomir. Margarito, Shane, and a lot of WW at that time were ducking the hard hitting baldomir. Then He Fought Hatton who was undefeated at that time. Many say Hatton was a 140 lbs fighter. But they either forgot or dont know Hatton had a belt at 147 after beating collazo at 147. So hatton was undefeated at 147 as well. He also fought Mosley when Mosley was coming off 2 back to make KOs and Floyd was coming off a 2 year lay off & a tune up with Marquez. Floyd dominated both those fighters. Floyd's JMW resume is also better then Pacquiaos. Pac fought Margarito a WW fighter at 150 for the 154lbs vacant belt. Margarito hadnt won any fights at 154 and had been off a whole year. Not only that he was fighting without his wraps. Floyd fought Oscar at 154 affter oscar ko mayorga and fernado vargus..

hahaha.. 1 Win in Collazo @WW = undefeated at WW....

So what makes it a big Win for Shane in a Margo without wraps then???

[Termite]

pacquiao. floyds only great win is against castillo. and dont tell me about coralles, he wasnt 100 percent when they fought.

[ADP02]

jmm didnt fight at 47 and pac will want to fight him at 47, so what will you say then?

What? Marquez fought Floyd at WW. So he did fight! He was in the same position as Manny in many of his fights of late.

The difference is that Marquez LOST to Floyd.

But I don't want to see Marquez vs Manny at 147 and I'm feeling not that much more enthused about 140.

[BrotherDudeJack]

no poll? i knew this thread was a joke.