true or false....sergio and floyd

[DIB42]

Lets not lose sight of the fact that Sergios win was very impressive. So was Floyds.

[IronDanHamza]

corrlaes was never in he top 5....he was top 9.....and even if he was , pwill was a top 5 also and better accomplished than corrales...this was about who has the better best win between sergio and floyd from the beginning , and it's clearly sergio.....

Corales was #5 in the year 2000. Look it up.

Williams was also #5 but he wasn't #1 at the weight class fought infact, he wasn't even ranked.

Williams was more accomplished at the time, but what does that matter? Your asking what the better win is.

Roy Jones is more accomplished than Mikel Kessler, does that make Calzaghe's win over Jones better than his win over Kessler? No.

The fact is Corales was #1 at the weight class fought and coming off impressive wins.

Paul Williams wasn't....

[DIB42]

wtf!...i never said such bs.....get the **** out my thread idiot...

I never said you "said" it. I was just using your logic to give you an alternative scenerio.

You're losing this argument BTW.

GG

[badass316]

sergio beating pwil by KO in round 2 is better than anything floyd has EVER done in his entire carreer.......true or false...as obvious as it is, i want to see *****s defend their case....lol...

Looking at it just as individual fights alone and not their whole body of work, I'd say yes. Sergio's KO win over Williams is better than anything Floyd has done. Floyd's win over Corrales was great, same with Castillo II, but if I remember correctly those two were not in the top 10 p4p list. Williams was #5 I believe when Sergio forcibly separated him from his consciousness.

[puga]

Corales was #5 in the year 2000. Look it up.

Williams was also #5 but he wasn't #1 at the weight class fought infact, he wasn't even ranked.

Williams was more accomplished at the time, but what does that matter? Your asking what the better win is.

Roy Jones is more accomplished than Mikel Kessler, does that make Calzaghe's win over Jones better than his win over Kessler? No.

The fact is Corales was #1 at the weight class fought and coming off impressive wins.

Paul Williams wasn't....

no he was'nt, he was # 9.....the better win depends on the bolded idiot....

[Chups]

Beating Mosley or Oscar >>>>> Pwill the nobody

[IronDanHamza]

no he was'nt, he was # 9.....the better win depends on the bolded idiot....

......Good lord.

He was #5 in the year 2000. Look it up. Grab a Ring Magazine from the year 2000. Search on the internet. In the year 2000, Diego Corales was P4P #5, and that is a fact.

The better win depends on who is more accomplished? Solely that? It doesn't matter that those accomplishments were over 2 years ago?

So Camacho's win over Leonard is better than Duran's win over Leonard is what your saying? Since Leonard was more 'accomplished' when he fought Camacho? It doesn't matter that he was coming off a loss at the time and looked utterly unimpressive? No?

How about Camachos win over Duran? Is that better than De Jesus's win over Duran? Since Duran was more 'accomplished' when he fought Camacho?

Obviously ****ing not.

[IronDanHamza]

Looking at it just as individual fights alone and not their whole body of work, I'd say yes. Sergio's KO win over Williams is better than anything Floyd has done. Floyd's win over Corrales was great, same with Castillo II, but if I remember correctly those two were not in the top 10 p4p list. Williams was #5 I believe when Sergio forcibly separated him from his consciousness.

Corales was P4P #5 in the year 2000.

[puga]

......Good lord.

He was #5 in the year 2000. Look it up. Grab a Ring Magazine from the year 2000. Search on the internet. In the year 2000, Diego Corales was P4P #5, and that is a fact.

The better win depends on who is more accomplished? Solely that? It doesn't matter that those accomplishments were over 2 years ago?

So Camacho's win over Leonard is better than Duran's win over Leonard is what your saying? Since Leonard was more 'accomplished' when he fought Camacho? It doesn't matter that he was coming off a loss at the time and looked utterly unimpressive? No?

How about Camachos win over Duran? Is that better than De Jesus's win over Duran? Since Duran was more 'accomplished' when he fought Camacho?

Obviously ****ing not.

were are not talking bout duran or camacho here dumb dumb...let's keep it simple....it's between the pwil who fought sergio vs the corrales that fought floyd......the chicho that floyd beat had wins over manfreedy and rbert garcia......the pwill that sergio beat had wins over margo, winky and quintana......is'nt it as clear as day light who was the better fighter between the two?......it should be commone sense but i guess it aint so common ..i have you and the *****s as a proof so far.....lol

[Real King Kong]

mofo...it was you who said corrales was # 3 and im the one who was'nt around the sport then...lol,,then all of a sudden he becomes # 5...lol....just admit you did'nt know corrlaes 's place in the p4p at that time.....do you not read, ive already stated that correla never had a better win than pwill's win over sergio, margo or quintana...that should be a common knowledge to boxing fans, i guess you aint........

outside of beating pwill...quintana hasn't done much. i don't know why you keep bringing up quintana like he's a world beater. the first time he stepped up to the top level he got dominated by cotto.