Higher p4p Martinez or Donaire

[IronDanHamza]

It's Sergio right now.

[KnockUTheFukOut]

Realistically he will likely be #4, Ring Mag already had him #5 behind JMM

but let be honest, none of these Publications is going to take Mayweather out of their P4P List even though he should be removed since he is not fighting right now but he and Pacquiao will remain the Top 2 with Martinez 3rd and Donaire 4th

NO WAY he leaps over the FIGHTER OF THE YEAR just because of 1 damn fight, you guys are RIDICULOUS!

[DARKSEID]

ohhh??? so he didnt beat a prime margarito as well?? he didnt beat sergio martinez??? interesting. once again williams has a better resume than montiel. i dont even kno why u are here arguing.

he(margarito) wasnt anything special. but how good he actually was will always remain a mystery. cotto beat the living **** outta him for half of a fight and then he made a spectacular comeback. thats his best win and even that is clouded in su****ion. margarito is not a hofer

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=439059&highlight=Margarito&page=2

Also, you don't add the guy who beat you the first fight with fixed scoring and who knocked you the hell out on the second fight on your resume.

dumbass.

[Swag Hustla]

Donaire by a hair. Donaire is still young and hasnt reached his prime yet as well.

I have Sergio by a hair.

Only because Martinez has been facing stiff competition consistently for the last 2 few years, even though I think Montiel is a better fighter than anyone Martinez beat.

But Donaire is right behind him. And if he beats another top Bantam like Moreno or Agbeko, then I would put him over Martinez.

[analog 2]

__________

[Kagami Taiga]

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...rgarito&page=2

Also, you don't add the guy who beat you the first fight with fixed scoring and who knocked you the hell out on the second fight on your resume.

dumbass.

lol...u, my friend need to let it go. i dont like margarito, i think he was overrated. he was still the best ww not named floyd at the time paul williams beat him. he still was fringe on many ppls p4p list. and why the hell cant u could a guy that beat u if u beat him first? that logic is ******. ur making no sense and u think u are...smh. dont hurt urself.

the point is williams is has a better resume that both those fighters and, AND, he was a p4p fighter when martinez beat him. ur argument is ****.

[Pullcounter]

I was thinking about it, then the HBO guys talked about it.

Both just after scoring devastating 2nd rd KOs against TOP quality opposition.

Who do u have higher now?

I have donaire above wifebeater and martinez. if pac doesn't KTFO mosley or if he doesn't fight any quality opponents soon, I might have nonito above pac too.

[chinoy]

Donaire should be higher than Martinez....
remember Pwill was MOVING UP in weight when he was starched by Martinez, the middle weight champ....

Montiel on the other hand was the WBO, WBC bantamweight champ and Donaire KTFO Montiel

[BigStereotype]

Nonito's the better fighter with more ahead of him. Sergio is 36, remember. This makes it SEEM like Donaire's the obvious p4p number 3 (I still rate Mayweather), but hold on. Martinez beat top 5 Paul Williams by brutal knockout (just as bad as this one), embarrassed Kelly Pavlik, some would say got robbed against Williams and definitely got robbed against Cintron. He's got a far superior resume at this point, but if Donaire goes onto beat some more good guys in top fashion, he goes ahead of Martinez and soon.

[Shadows]

I was thinking about it, then the HBO guys talked about it.

Both just after scoring devastating 2nd rd KOs against TOP quality opposition.

Who do u have higher now?

I think Donaire is the better fighter, but Martinez has beaten the better competition lately.

A win over the Showtime winner or Moreno and I'd put Donaire ahead.