Higher p4p Martinez or Donaire

[DARKSEID]

Honestly, at this point I'd have to say Donaire.

Martinez is on that list because he looked great against pavlik and destroyed williams..

but Donaire destroyed Sidorenko and DEMOLISHED Montiel- Montiel is a much better quality opponent PFP than williams and even sidorenko over the overhyped pavlik.

Montiel beat the higher quality opponents, and in more impressive fashion. I say Donaire is number 3 right now.

[Kagami Taiga]

i dont mind him being #3 but manny and serg are still ahead of him, no doubt about it. floyd is and should probably be dropped from the list and im a fan of his. those three(well really 2 because manny is on sum bull**** rite now) are tearing up boxing singlehandedly.

[hanzoh74]

Yay!! Hurray for my boy Donaire!! next stop 122lbs Arce or Vasquez!! Lets get it on!!

[Kagami Taiga]

Honestly, at this point I'd have to say Donaire.

Martinez is on that list because he looked great against pavlik and destroyed williams..

but Donaire destroyed Sidorenko and DEMOLISHED Montiel- Montiel is a much better quality opponent PFP than williams and even sidorenko over the overhyped pavlik.

Montiel beat the higher quality opponents, and in more impressive fashion. I say Donaire is number 3 right now.

u dont kno wat ur talking about. williams beat much more higher quality opponnents than either montiel or donaire and so did sergio for that matter.

[hanzoh74]

i had Donaire climb 1 slot up for now but not overtake Martinez yet...a couple of high caliber fights then hes no.2

[Jcsuper]

I have

1 - Pac
2 - Martinez
3 - Donaire

Floyd is out cause that ***** is never fighting, so I don't know why I should care about putting him in my rankings. Thats sad cause this guy is a genius in the ring.

Pac also has to watch his ass, if he continues to cherrypick and Martinez/Donaire continues to defeat top opposition, he'll get out of the number 1 spot. He's opposition lately has been deceiving has hell

[DARKSEID]

u dont kno wat ur talking about. williams beat much more higher quality opponnents than either montiel or donaire and so did sergio for that matter.

And you don't know how to talk to people.

A shot and battle worn Winky Wright who just lost to a 45 year old Hopkins and just had a draw with over-hyped J-taylor is the biggest name on William's resume

While Montiel has been an undefeated, almost undisputed champion for almost a decade- he should be the lineal bantamweight champion.

Unless you want to argue that Carlos Quintana is an under appreciated under-rated ATG(lol) which would justify why williams lost to him the first time.

[gingeralbino]

i still have Pac and Floyd 1 and 2. But they need to get their act together. Cant split Donaire and Martinez atm.

[Kagami Taiga]

And you don't know how to talk to people.

A shot and battle worn Winky Wright who just lost to a 45 year old Hopkins and just had a draw with over-hyped J-taylor is the biggest name on William's resume

While Montiel has been an undefeated, almost undisputed champion for almost a decade- he should be the lineal bantamweight champion.

ohhh??? so he didnt beat a prime margarito as well?? he didnt beat sergio martinez??? interesting. once again williams has a better resume than montiel. i dont even kno why u are here arguing.

[Las Vegas,]

Martinez for sure. Donaire is easily 3rd though.