Higher p4p Martinez or Donaire

[gingeralbino]

I think Donaire is the better fighter, but Martinez has beaten the better competition lately.

A win over the Showtime winner or Moreno and I'd put Donaire ahead.

after watching all those fights u and walt reccomended i want to see him fight both of them. **** moving up in weight. the BW division is stacked!

[Shadows]

after watching all those fights u and walt reccomended i want to see him fight both of them. **** moving up in weight. the BW division is stacked!

You watched them all? Good man.

You should check out Tapia-Ayala I, just for the fact it's a great fight.

[THRILLAinmanila]

Paging Mr. Cliff Rold...you didn't even put Donaire in your "could easily be here" spot in your Top 10 P4P list...Heck, you didn't even mention him his name in your "could be here soon " list.... I guess it now time for you to update your list ASAP, and agree with Ring's Top 10 ranking of Nonito...:P

[Check_hooks]

Lets take a look at Martinezs resume. His last fight was against Pwill who had to move up in weight to fight him. And while he did knock him out hes still 1-1 against Pwill. His fight against Kelly Pavlik doesnt really mean much cuz Kelly doesn't have it anymore and has personal problem like being an alcholic. He also got a draw against Kermit Cintron 4 fights ago. And he has said he's only after a payday which is why hes ducking Pirog. Nonito said he wants to become undisputed at BW and is willing to move up. Thats a heart of a champion right there.

Donaire looks more spectacular against better fighters and is younger and has less loses on his resume.

My list is

1.) Manny Pacquiao
2.) Nonito Donaire
3.) Carl Froch
4.) Wlad/Vitali Klitchko
5.) Martinez

[BigStereotype]

Lets take a look at Martinezs resume. His last fight was against Pwill who had to move up in weight to fight him. And while he did knock him out hes still 1-1 against Pwill. His fight against Kelly Pavlik doesnt really mean much cuz Kelly doesn't have it anymore and has personal problem like being an alcholic. He also got a draw against Kermit Cintron 4 fights ago.

Donaire looks more spectacular against better fighters and is younger and has less loses on his resume.

My list is

1.) Manny Pacquiao
2.) Nonito Donaire
3.) Carl Froch
4.) Wlad/Vitali Klitchko
5.) Martinez

Sergio Martinez makes Carl Froch look like a ****** for 12 rounds. That's not even close. Froch number 3? Really? And I agree that Donaire has been more explosive, but Martinez should have had the win against Cintron (watch that fight and tell me Cintron deserves a draw) and arguably won his first with Williams. That fight was clearly only gonna be won by Paul, one judge had it 118-110...Martinez still has that resume.

Lol at the Klitschko Brothers as one entity and them being p4p number 4. Wlad is higher than Vitali, and is only barely top 10 if he is at all.

[gingeralbino]

You watched them all? Good man.

You should check out Tapia-Ayala I, just for the fact it's a great fight.

all the ones i could get, a few of Cermeno's were hard to come by along with one or 2 others. Havent watched the other ones u pmed me about yet though

[huthut]

Both Don and Serg seem interchangeable for now. Don has better potential to become one of the ATG, at the moment.

[Check_hooks]

Sergio Martinez makes Carl Froch look like a ****** for 12 rounds. That's not even close. Froch number 3? Really? And I agree that Donaire has been more explosive, but Martinez should have had the win against Cintron (watch that fight and tell me Cintron deserves a draw) and arguably won his first with Williams. That fight was clearly only gonna be won by Paul, one judge had it 118-110...Martinez still has that resume.

Lol at the Klitschko Brothers as one entity and them being p4p number 4. Wlad is higher than Vitali, and is only barely top 10 if he is at all.

Froch would beat Martinez easy. He only has 1 loss which everone knows is bs because it was fought in Kesslers backyard. While Martinez lost to a raw Margarito and Pwill. I'm not so sure he would beat Pwill if they fought a rubber match. I had to put he Klits up there because no one has dominated their divison this era as much as the Klit bros have. So really I have Martinez at 6 p4p.

[AFighter4U]

ATM, i say Sergio Martinez over Donaire. IMHO at the end Donaire will prevail.

[mathed]

Easy for me, I love both fighters (as boxers solely, to all the freaks on here) but Martinez wins easy. The dude fights bigger guys and puts up with the fact that the powers that be don't really want him to win. He is just now being accepted but his personality is that of a marketable star, he has morals and a good speaking presence.

Martinez is the guy that no-one wants to face, Donaire is the guy that slightly bigger guys want to test until they actually get into the ring; Sergio just doesn't have the stigma associated with fighting smaller opponents.