So the Ring has bumped Devon alexander to #4

[wizard king]

I'm surprised Maidana is rated so highly, when we all know he is a one-dimensional brawler with zero boxing skills and has an overrated win over the coward Ortiz and got his ass dropped by Khan. Not to mention Kotelnik has a win over him and an arguable win over Devon, too.

while this may be true, madina has the equalier and thats his power and his power is not orrated like many tend to think.

[JmH Reborn]

I think those are fair rankings. Kotelnik seems like a guy who will always give a great showing, but fall just a hair short.

I think Maidana is right where he should be. Even though he got KD against Khan, he came back and closed the gap. I think he'd beat Alexander, and perhaps Bradley as well. I also think him v. Kahn would be another great one.

I hope these guys stay at 140 just a little longer...I see great fights coming up

[FeFist]

So if the judges had Margarito winning against Pacquiao you would seriously rank him higher and believe he is the better fighter?

If that happened the fight would probably be ruled a no contest. Senseless comparison anyway as Kotelnik v Alexander was a close fight, Pacquiao v Margarito was a one sided beat down.