if martinez defeats dzinziruk should he be no.1 p4p

[-DSG-]

?????????????????????????????????????????????????? ??

[Russian Crushin]

Must be a joke

I will try and give you a somewhat complicated yet dignified response.

NO!

[-DSG-]

Must be a joke

I will try and give you a somewhat complicated yet dignified response.

NO!

why not???

[Ogecca MaMa]

If he defeats Dzin., he should be straight 3rd.

[Left Hook Tua]

why not???

p4p rankings is based on a lot of things.

it's not just based on 1-2 good years.


he trails behind pac and floyd in career accomplishments.

pac and floyd are seen as better skilled as well.

[Khalid X]

Absolutely not, and what kinda question is this?

[Left Hook Tua]

If he defeats Dzin., he should be straight 3rd.

i think he deserves #3 now.

i have no problem with anyone who has him #3 currently behind floyd and pac.

[King Ju-Ju]

why???? pacquiao cant lose his sopt without actually losing. floyd lost his spot at 1 and then at 2 when he retired and went on vacation.

[Clegg]

No, I don't think Dzin has proven himself as an elite-level fighter.

[Left Hook Tua]

why???? pacquiao cant lose his sopt without actually losing. floyd lost his spot at 1 and then at 2 when he retired and went on vacation.

you can lose a #1 spot without losing.

problem is martinez wasn't even close to #1.

if he was already #2-3 before he beat pavlik and williams then you might have a case for having him go above pac/floyd.

but he wasn't.

his wins over pavlik and williams got him in the top 10.