Comments Thread For: Closing 2010: BoxingScene.com’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Shadows]

The only time I can remember Moreno being hurt was when he was wobbled by a Cermeno right hand in the first fight. He was able to survive the round and Cermeno's following onslaught by using his defensive skills along the ropes.

Though, Cermeno isn't really a puncher and not known for his finishing skills, so you can say that doesn't cut it. Plus, he may not have been hurt badly enough.

Bantamweight is just damn good right now. People talke about Montiel, Donaire, and those in the tourney, but fighters like Moreno and Cermeno fly under the radar.

[S IP U IR S xII]

My Revision

I would tweak list slightly.....MY OPINION.....YOU DONT LIKE IT, COOL. ITS OK TO DISAGREE, BUT DONT GO NUTS IF ITS NOT HOW YOU SEE FIT.


1. Sergio Martinez - Destroyed the dangerous Pavlik & avoided Williams.
2. Pac - Dominating year agian, but gets heat for choosing Margarito.
3. Klitschko- Another dominating year. Not K's fault Haye is scared is it?
4. Hopkins- No explanation really needed. He just continues to win.
5. JMM-Great wins over Katisidis and Diaz. Makes case for Pac 3.
6. Floyd-You have to fight more than 1x a year. Lucky hes this high.
7. Andre Ward- Hes the best in super 6 & Green match was masterful.
8. Bradley-09 was more active year, but good win over Abregu.
9. Khan-Cant leave him off. Beat slick Paulie & KO king Miadana.
10.Montiel-KO's over Soto and Concepcion while preparing for Donaire

[mathed]

Good list but Sergio shoud be like 3 on there. By next year, Bradley will be number 4 or 5 and Sergio will be 2 after Mayweather is doing a 5-10 stint.

[WESS]

How is Martinez not TOP 3 or even #1?

He's done more this year than the top 3 guys listed IMO....

[cleaner147]

I think Donaire's impressive KO of Sidorenko was way more pulsating than the two fights with Moreno. tell me if Im wrong...

[Tomasio]

I would have Sergio Martinez #1 & Juan Manuel Marquez #2

[RIZO24]

The list is pretty accurate except i would remove the #9 wonjong "whatever" for Humberto Soto!! Did anyone notice no Puero Ricans on the top 10 P4P??? Two Mexicans And Soto should be there!! so three!! Puerto Rico Zerote!!lol

[crold1]

I think Donaire's impressive KO of Sidorenko was way more pulsating than the two fights with Moreno. tell me if Im wrong...

Agree. Chavez's KO's of Greg Haugen and Roger Mayweather were more pulsating than Pernell Whitaker decisions over them as well.

[cleaner147]

Agree. Chavez's KO's of Greg Haugen and Roger Mayweather were more pulsating than Pernell Whitaker decisions over them as well.

mhh idk if you really can compare these fighters with eachother. to see such a brave and disciplined man like Sidorenko snapping and streaming with blood was something strange and special...

[Piper the Great]

Sorry.....but, are you going to tell me you've been a member since '07 (which probably means you've been a fan much longer I'm guessing...or maybe not) but haven't heard of Wongjongkam?

Man, get to it! Go find his early fights. Exciting guy and very, very good. Reminds me of Sahaprom, in that he was the best bantamweight (not that Wongjongkam is BW but you know what I mean) in the world and an absolutely incredible fighter but no one had even heard of him. Sad.

ima look him up but I see his next fight is with a guy that's 5-6. maybe this is why he not getting exposure