Boxingscenes Top10 P4P on pg.1

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • QueenCity
    the Cincinnati kid
    Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
    • Jul 2004
    • 838
    • 47
    • 58
    • 7,353

    #21
    I have some issues with the rakings Jose, mainly if you keep Hopkins at 5 you have to have Taylor at least in the top 10. Also I would for sure put Berrea and Winky in the top 5. And Rafeal Marquez was getting out classed by Tim Austin until Austin got a little reckless in the 8th..... but its all objective though everybodys gonna have a diffrent opinion

    Comment

    • !! Mr. Soprano
      THE BOSS
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Mar 2005
      • 7106
      • 576
      • 2,446
      • 16,129

      #22
      this is not the worst list I've seen, but it's very close to it

      Comment

      • Sir_Jose
        El Guapo
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Dec 2003
        • 4935
        • 424
        • 383
        • 13,646

        #23
        NOBODY will ever agree on a p4p list. You can take list from FSN, ESPN, Ring, KO etc.. and people will pick them apart all day long in favor of fighters they like.

        Comment

        • tracylee
          B Scene's Julia Roberts
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Apr 2004
          • 8181
          • 588
          • 865
          • 16,433

          #24
          Originally posted by Sir_Jose
          NOBODY will ever agree on a p4p list. You can take list from FSN, ESPN, Ring, KO etc.. and people will pick them apart all day long in favor of fighters they like.
          this is true. I've yet to see any two that match.

          Comment

          • oldgringo
            Ellis
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Jul 2004
            • 12747
            • 968
            • 453
            • 30,064

            #25
            I just don't see how you can have a top 5 that doesn't include these guys:

            Mayweather
            Morales
            Hopkins
            Wright
            R Marquez

            I think those uys are undoubtedly the 5 best fighters in the world right now...and are definitely the best fighters in their given weight class (yes Hopkins is still better than Taylor ****ers)

            Comment

            • Slipx
              Lethal Barefisted
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Jan 2005
              • 3030
              • 133
              • 236
              • 9,967

              #26
              wright needs to be in front of pac, sorry

              think about it..wright is ****ing invincible when I watch him fight he reminds me of like a hacker or something in a video game owning everyone with an unfair advantage.

              i mean he ****ted on tito hardcore

              and not only that, in his previous fights its the same way, invincible defense

              he will be the next hopkins.
              Last edited by Slipx; 08-27-2005, 04:20 PM.

              Comment

              • Tha Greatest
                boxingscene legend
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Jul 2004
                • 15748
                • 616
                • 963
                • 24,468

                #27
                Originally posted by Slipx
                wright needs to be in front of pac, sorry

                think about it..wright is ****ing invincible when I watch him fight he reminds me of like a hacker or something in a video game owning everyone with an unfair advantage.

                i mean he ****ted on tito hardcore

                and not only that, in his previous fights its the same way, invincible defense

                he will be the next hopkins.
                I like how u appreciate good boxers intstead of the just exciting ones..

                props.

                Comment

                • Manny_P
                  Knicks/Yankees/Giants
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • May 2005
                  • 8966
                  • 542
                  • 799
                  • 19,102

                  #28
                  nyahahahahahahahaha. Out of all ta fightas on ta list, ONLY PACMAN entered ta BUILDING rightfully. He ****in smothered Barrera into smitherins who was P4P #3 on many lists at that time! ONly Pacman jest bulldozed his way to ta list NO arguments. It sucks that Maywetha...Hopkins..... become #1 jest becuz ta top dawg lost! Roy Jones lost....Hopkins become #1! WHY?????HOW????? Fo beating Robert Allen? nyahahahaha. what a joke. Mayweatha becomes #1, WHY???? HOW???? Becuz he beat ta amazing Arturro Gatti who he been sayin is a class C bum??? Nope. becuz Hopkins LOST! ****in lame. Don't criticize Pacman no mo bitches becuz unlike all these people on ta list, PACMAN HAS TA MOST IMPRESSIVE VICTORY AND BEATING OF A HIGHLY RANKED P4P FIGHTA IN BARRERA! **** outta here! Hatton won gainst Tszyu in a very close fight (his 1st win gainst a quality foe), KOO! Corrales won gainst a NON P4P fighta in Castillo IN A CLOSE FIGHT. KOO! Winky won gainst a non ranked P4P (not even top 15) fighta gainst Tito, KOO! Judah won gainst Spinks who wasn't in P4P ranking, KOO!

                  ONLY PACMAN HAS TA MOST IMPRESSIVE WIN GAINST A TOP DAWG ON that P4P list. It's a ****in stoopid thing to omit Pacman on ta top 10 lists eitha, who eva's shyt list was that I saw.

                  Comment

                  • Sir_Jose
                    El Guapo
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Dec 2003
                    • 4935
                    • 424
                    • 383
                    • 13,646

                    #29
                    Winky Wright= Shamelessy overrated. His wins are as hollow as they come.

                    Shane Mosley was washed up and went into that Winky Wright fight 1-1-2 in his last 4 and his 1 win was a highly contraversial win against DLH.

                    Tito Trinidad had 1 fight in the last 3 years going into that Wright fight. Wow Felix Trinidad cant deal with a jab and angels, NO **** wonder where we ween that before?

                    Both Tito and Wright were no where near the fighters they once were going into there fights with Winky.

                    Judah is 1-2 in his 3 biggest fighyts and hasn';t done anything worth mentioning execpt beat up 3rd rate journeymen recently.

                    Rafeal Marquez for those not paying attention is something special. Marquez is on his way to being an all time great Bantamweight. Saying he was even with Tim Austin is not a bad thing considering Austin is the best American Bantamweight since Jeff Chandler and a Hall Of Famer himself.

                    Comment

                    • Manny_P
                      Knicks/Yankees/Giants
                      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                      • May 2005
                      • 8966
                      • 542
                      • 799
                      • 19,102

                      #30
                      Originally posted by Sir_Jose
                      Winky Wright= Shamelessy overrated. His wins are as hollow as they come.

                      Shane Mosley was washed up and went into that Winky Wright fight 1-1-2 in his last 4 and his 1 win was a highly contraversial win against DLH.

                      Tito Trinidad had 1 fight in the last 3 years going into that Wright fight. Wow Felix Trinidad cant deal with a jab and angels, NO **** wonder where we ween that before?

                      Both Tito and Wright were no where near the fighters they once were going into there fights with Winky.

                      Judah is 1-2 in his 3 biggest fighyts and hasn';t done anything worth mentioning execpt beat up 3rd rate journeymen recently.

                      Rafeal Marquez for those not paying attention is something special. Marquez is on his way to being an all time great Bantamweight. Saying he was even with Tim Austin is not a bad thing considering Austin is the best American Bantamweight since Jeff Chandler and a Hall Of Famer himself.

                      ya i agree sumwhat, but goddman edit yer posts, nyahahahaha! Tito not fightin fo 3 years befo he fought Wright?

                      Tito and Wright not same fighta when they fought Winky????

                      (scratchin ma head)....and then ma balls cuz it's itchy right now. nyahahaha!

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP