Comments Thread For: Say It Isn’t So: Pacquiao Unworthy of 2010’s Top Honor

[jrosales13]

Simple answer to your question is Sergio and Pac. Nobody else.

Dafuckouttahere.

If Pascal beats Hopkins is Martinez then Pascal as the runner.

If Khan beats Maidana he would of had a better year than Pac.

As of right now it is Martinez, I would put Montiel, Juanma Lopez, and Segura in the 2, 3, and 4 spot all ahead of Pac for the year...

[Ravishing]

Well duh. Next year he won't be either. His 2 fights will most likely be against Mosley and a rematch with Cotto and Margarito.

Man, it sucks when the Top guy isn't giving the up and coming fighters and chance to claim his throne.

LOL oh the irony...

[marikudo]

Dafuckouttahere.

If Pascal beats Hopkins is Martinez then Pascal as the runner.

If Khan beats Maidana he would of had a better year than Pac.

As of right now it is Martinez, I would put Montiel, Juanma Lopez, and Segura in the 2, 3, and 4 spot all ahead of Pac for the year...

You're ranking is nonsense. I would put Pacquiao ahead of the field. He has fought bigger guys and winning the fights with ease. If you say Martinez is the FOTY because of his knockout of Williams, well I would say that Pacquiao's battering of an opponent 17 lbs heavier is the most impressive feat of any boxer that has ever done. Not even Ray Robinson or Henry Armstrong has done that.

[Sugar Q]

It's funny going into the PBF/Mosley people said Mosley (#3 P4P and #1 @ 147) would be PBF's toughest opponent then when PBF shut him down Mosley immediately became too old over night even though Manny Catchuiao wanted absolutely no part of him. I say that to say Pac shouldn't even be in this discussion. Martinez is definitely FOTY but PBF with the Mosley beatdown has to be 1st runner up. I still can't get over the fact that no one finds it odd that Manny refuses to submit to unrestricted OST.

[Mr. Philadel]

By Lyle Fitzsimmons - This wasn’t at all what I’d planned for the week.

As I enjoyed a flex-time Monday off from the real-life day job, my intent for this very column was to do a West Coast interview with a budding filmmaker in the evening, assemble a few other notes and put together 1,000 or so words of ersatz brilliance as I revved up for Jets-Patriots on ESPN.

But some weeks – as Rex Ryan can now surely attest – are better than others.

As I waited for a few pre-interview logistics to work themselves out, I tooled over to check the latest goings-on at Facebook, where several of my colleagues periodically coagulate for discussions of all things boxing – be they historic, futuristic or controversial in nature. [Click Here To Read More]

nice article ....can't believe I'm sayin this to a non-Jake write up!!

[Apple Mac]

Dafuckouttahere.

If Pascal beats Hopkins is Martinez then Pascal as the runner.

If Khan beats Maidana he would of had a better year than Pac.

As of right now it is Martinez, I would put Montiel, Juanma Lopez, and Segura in the 2, 3, and 4 spot all ahead of Pac for the year...

Why would i Daf-uckouttahere? Are you the owner of this site? If you dont agree to my statement then you are free to have yours.
Your claims doesnt make sense anyway. "peeleft:

[JoeDaWg]

Martinez deserves it this year, no doubt. Thats not taking anything away from what pac did, he's still tha man, I was just more impressed by what martinez was able to do this year. Even mj didn't win the mvp every year he played, martinez is a beast and he deserves it in 2010!

[Apple Mac]

Dafuckouttahere.

If Pascal beats Hopkins is Martinez then Pascal as the runner.

If Khan beats Maidana he would of had a better year than Pac.

As of right now it is Martinez, I would put Montiel, Juanma Lopez, and Segura in the 2, 3, and 4 spot all ahead of Pac for the year...

As I said, I agree with Martinez as the top FOTY but saying Montiel, Lopez and Segura ahead of Pac is a clear BS. Your basing your claims just from your hatred and not from the game's whole perspective.

[JoeDaWg]

It's funny going into the PBF/Mosley people said Mosley (#3 P4P and #1 @ 147) would be PBF's toughest opponent then when PBF shut him down Mosley immediately became too old over night even though Manny Catchuiao wanted absolutely no part of him. I say that to say Pac shouldn't even be in this discussion. Martinez is definitely FOTY but PBF with the Mosley beatdown has to be 1st runner up. I still can't get over the fact that no one finds it odd that Manny refuses to submit to unrestricted OST.

This isn't a woman beating contest, floyd don't have no place in the top 5 of this list bro.

[jrosales13]

You're ranking is nonsense. I would put Pacquiao ahead of the field. He has fought bigger guys and winning the fights with ease. If you say Martinez is the FOTY because of his knockout of Williams, well I would say that Pacquiao's battering of an opponent 17 lbs heavier is the most impressive feat of any boxer that has ever done. Not even Ray Robinson or Henry Armstrong has done that.

Why would i Daf-uckouttahere? Are you the owner of this site? If you dont agree to my statement then you are free to have yours.
Your claims doesnt make sense anyway. "peeleft:

STFU,

neither Clottey nor Marg were better than Marg or P-Will. And, if Pascal win neither one of them would be better than Dawson or Hopkins,

Neither one of them were as skilled as Calderon, and Segura stopped him. Segura also beat a sold fighter in Vargas in short week notice and stopped which makes it more impressive. Segura went 4-0 this year with 4 KO's and one of them against F'ing Calderon man.

Neither one of them ranked higher than Hasegawa, And, now that Hasegawa is competing at FW just shows you how much bigger he was than Montiel who started at flyweight. Montiel has gone 3-0 with 3KO's this year and one of them against F'ing Hasegawa and has another fight this Saturday.

Juanma went 3-0 against top 10 in his division this year. And, KO'd all 3 top 10 featherweights. Pac can't touch that this year.

You say that Pac beat a guy 17 pound heavier and that "NOT EVEN SRR and Armstrong has done that." Which shows how dumb you're cuz yes they have.

Valuev was close to 100 pounds bigger and 9" taller than Haye. So F'ing what? Even this year Harrison was 3" taller and like 40 pounds heaver. Why is that not a big deal?

WTF are you guys talking about? Pac is not in the discussion this year.