Comments Thread For: Say It Isn’t So: Pacquiao Unworthy of 2010’s Top Honor

[warayupay]

wow! Lyle chose the word "unworthy"?
Pac is a candidate but obviously, Martinez beats him to it.
But saying "unworthy" is a different thing...

[Boxing's Truth]

Another guy to mention who didn't have a bad year was Juanma. But his time will come.

But this goes to show you that even with two convincing and dominating victories the voters chose not to give it to Pac because he beat two bums.

They felt that Sergio's victories over Pav and P-Will were better wins.

[WESS]

Who really thinks Pac should be FOTY?

There is no argument. The Klits have done more. Mayweather has done more just in his ONE fight, while Pac beat a #5 WW and a non ranked fighter. If anyone should be FOTY its Martinez.

Are we lowering the standards for this award too? Are they going to make a "diamond" FOTY award?

[King Ju-Ju]

sergio martinez winning the middleweight title and then knocking out paul williams in their rematch is way better then pacquiao beating joshua "the stationary punching bag" clottey and antonio "the moving punching bag" margarito

[GStalker]

An excellent read it is as those *******s often go as far as to name Manny Pacquiao (who is hands down the most deserved P4P #1 as of now) 2010 FOTY. So, a little teaser should make up for loads of foam from some mouths, khe-khe... Great job!

On the other hand, bringing on only Martinez, Klitschko and, say, Pascal names is not smarter on my mind. Those guys as Fernando Montiel (IF successful tonight) and Giovanni Segura deserve the same mention, maybe even stronger. They are often overlooked but to me their achievements are pretty darn impressive as well... Peace...

[King Ju-Ju]

An excellent read it is as those *******s often go as far as to name Manny Pacquiao (who is hands down the most deserved P4P #1 as of now) 2010 FOTY. So, a little teaser should make up for loads of foam from some mouths, khe-khe... Great job!

On the other hand, bringing on only Martinez, Klitschko and, say, Pascal names is not smarter on my mind. Those guys as Fernando Montiel (IF successful tonight) and Giovanni Segura deserve the same mention, maybe even stronger. They are often overlooked but to me their achievements are pretty darn impressive as well... Peace...

sergio is foty imo but id give it 2 segura b4 pacquiao

[PACnPBFsuck]

Sergio beat the WBC & WBO champ Kelly "the Ghost" Pavlik for 12 rounds then defended the title against Paul "the punisher" Williams(was P4P #3) at williams catchweight request and knocked him out.

How is that resume not a fighter of year resume?

[FloydTBE]

no way even pac is in top 5 of foty. hes done nothing

[Georgeshills]

martinez should be FOTY. Pacquiao's 2010 record is not even close.

[NesNY]

Maravilla quite easily takes this year's honors. Fighter of the Year and Knockout of the Year should be awarded to one Sergio "Maravilla" Martinez.

Fight of the year...interesting. I like JMM so I'll say JMM/Kats.