Comments Thread For: Say It Isn’t So: Pacquiao Unworthy of 2010’s Top Honor

[jrosales13]

No Shit

Martinez or hops if he wins are the fighters of the year even pascal is more deserving based on his 1 fight against Dawson


Manny is not even a top 5

Hell no!!!!!!!!

Even if he beats Pascal he would not be in the running not even ahead of Pac. His showing against Roy Jones this yea can not put him in the discussion.

If he beats Pascal he can get comeback FOTY but not thee FOTY.

Now if Pascal wins he should be runner up of FOTY behind Martinez.

[jrosales13]

Who really thinks Pac should be FOTY?

There is no argument. The Klits have done more. Mayweather has done more just in his ONE fight, while Pac beat a #5 WW and a non ranked fighter. If anyone should be FOTY its Martinez.

Are we lowering the standards for this award too? Are they going to make a "diamond" FOTY award?

You letting your hate or fan boyism get the better of you.

One why are you putting both brothers together? And, how the hell has Vitaly done more than Pac? He has wins over Briggs and Sosnowski this year. How is that doing more? Pac beat the #5 WW like you mentioned neither Briggs or Sosnowski are top 15 HWs. So really WTF are you talking about?

[jrosales13]

AND LYLE???

Are Fitzimmons and Wallace from ESB obsessed by Pacquiao??
I NEVER SAW such haters in the boxing media.
If Pacquiao was an american from brooklyn,he would be their semi god.

Pacquiao is far to cherry pick and fighting bums like Jones and Mayweather did.

SERGIO IS THE FOTY YES!!!
But Pavlik and Williams aren't so much better than Margo and Clottey.

Yes they're

Just to say Pacquiao isn't so "unworthy",I would say he takes maybe the 2nd spot.

No he doesn't, I can name a handful of opponents who have had a better year than Pac this year. Hell if Khan beats Maidana he would of had a better year also.

[Apple Mac]

Maravilla quite easily takes this year's honors. Fighter of the Year and Knockout of the Year should be awarded to one Sergio "Maravilla" Martinez.

Fight of the year...interesting. I like JMM so I'll say JMM/Kats.

I Agree with Martinez but saying that Marquez as FOTY because you only like him does not make him a strong candidate. FOTY is based on intensity and excitement of the fight and 1 fighter is just a factor.

[Gino Ros]

If Pacquiao was an american from brooklyn,he would be their semi god.
.

If Pacquiao was an American from Brooklyn, he wouldn't have had those fights. The only reason mismatch after mismatcj gets made is because there are a million little pudgy midgets who will buy Manny's fight no matter what. And money rules.

[Gino Ros]

I Agree with Martinez but saying that Marquez as FOTY because you only like him does not make him a strong candidate. FOTY is based on intensity and excitement of the fight and 1 fighter is just a factor.

Then name a better candidate for Fight of the Year, then.

[Gino Ros]

But Pavlik and Williams aren't so much better than Margo and Clottey.
.

How can you say that when Williams already beat a prime Marg, and you know that Williams would take 12 rounds from Clottey in a rout?

Pavlik and Williams were titleholders who had top ten p4p slots.

[Apple Mac]

Then name a better candidate for Fight of the Year, then.

Simple answer to your question is Sergio and Pac. Nobody else.

[parabellum]

The difference is that Pac has come up multiple weight divisions to beat the guys he is beating now while Martinez is beating guys around his weight class.
What is more impressive?
I think that it is hard to top a former flyweight who beats a junior middleweight.

[Apple Mac]

Then name a better candidate for Fight of the Year, then.

ANd if you want to argue, I'll give you Floyd. He beat SSM, Josie Harris, Mr. Security Guard. 3 fight in a year, How can you compete with that?