Should Sugar Shane Mosley Still Be Considered Great?

[Truth]

Remember when it looked as though Sugar Shane was going to be in the hall of fame with the other two sugars? Is that status all gone or do you think he could rescue his career at 147? I personally believe Shane ruined his career. I like Shane but he put himself in some fights that were almost impossible for him to win. Whats your opinion?

[everlast99]

if he stayed at lightweight he would definately be in the hall of fame...he was so fast and strong i think he could have been the best lightweight ever, better then duran imo

[Memorex]

if he stayed at lightweight he would definately be in the hall of fame...he was so fast and strong i think he could have been the best lightweight ever, better then duran imo

i agree woth ya but i dont know about better than duran o yea dont let tha greatest see ur sig lol

[TheEvilSaint]

no, he had freak wins over DLH and got his ass whooped by forest and winky twice. hes 1-4-0-1 in the light middle division. he shouldve stayed in welter.

[Parodius]

I still think Sugar Shane accomplished more then Roy Jones. If people gonna consider Roy Jones great, then Sugar Shane should also be considered great.

[Tarver is my dad]

he's still a legend in my eyes...

[DANGER13]

he is not hall of fame material. he beat de la hoya once. dats not all dat great. he needs a couple big wins be 4 u could even consider him hall of fame. he lost 2 de la hoya in the second bout, forrest twice, and winky twice.

[Truth]

I still think Sugar Shane accomplished more then Roy Jones. If people gonna consider Roy Jones great, then Sugar Shane should also be considered great.

Really? How does that work?

[Truth]

How is Shane Mosley greater than Roy?

[TheEvilSaint]

How is Shane Mosley greater than Roy?

hes not.

roy jones was the 2nd person in history to go from middleweight to win the HW title (the first was Bob Fitzsimmons, and the 3rd was James Toney). for that sole accomplishment, roy jones has my respect... sort of.