posters on here argued with me last night that shane,margo had better resumes than

[-MAKAVELLI-]

resumes=wins....if yiou counted loses journey men would have the best resumes

some can argue that Shane's wins over a prime and peak DLH would trump anything Floyd has done

[infamous larryx]

margos best win=cotto,clottey,cintron,

shanes=oscar,vargas,mayorga

[infamous larryx]

reggie strickland is the greatest of all time.

lol..........................................

[Left Hook Tua]

did they fight better competition? yes
did they always win? no
is that why floyd doesn't fight tough competition? yes

i love this guy.


can you throw in a calzaghe rant to make my day?

[infamous larryx]

some can argue that Shane's wins over a prime and peak DLH would trump anything Floyd has done

yep those same "some" that dont give floyd credit for anything

[jrosales13]

margos best win=cotto,clottey,cintron,

I would say those 3 wins are better...

shanes=oscar,vargas,mayorga

Than those 2 wins

Agree?

[shogunn]

floyd

oscar
corrales
castillo
hatton
shane
judah
hernendez



no need to list jmm

why is JMM in his resume in the first place, while shane the rest of the WWs mentioned have middleweights.

[jrosales13]

yep those same "some" that dont give floyd credit for anything

Which Floyd win do you think is better than the first Oscar win for Shane?

[Left Hook Tua]

some can argue that Shane's wins over a prime and peak DLH would trump anything Floyd has done

that's a no-brainer.

mosley beat a delahoya who a lot thought should still be undefeated since many thought he beat tito a year earlier.

[infamous larryx]

why is JMM in his resume in the first place, while shane the rest of the WWs mentioned have middleweights.

it is what it is..but i didnt even list him