Shane mosley is overrated??????

[JAYDA CRUZE]

jmm is a bit overarted....being at 3 is way too high for him imo, montiel should be # 3!....

thats laughable!

[puga]

JMM is not overrated, he's up there with Barrera and Morales.

yes he is right now....beating a juan diaz aint really much after lossing,(i know floyd's win was laughable but he still lost) that all he's done lately!...

[puga]

thats laughable!

it's laughable coz thats all you can say....

and i agree with the ts....hoya >>>>>>>>shane by miles!

[gibo]

If SSM is overrated, then that has to mean delahoja is a fraud. SS beat him twice, and was smaller than hoja. delahoja said he'd fight the winner of the COTTO MARGARITO fight. He never did. While SSM fought BOTH. Lost to one and almost killed the other. SSM OVERRATED??? Think again Haters!!!

[MidnightSpecial]

Shane is a hall of famer with a hall of fame career.

people let fighters late fights swing their opinion too much.

Shane was SCARY in his prime

[S IP U IR S xII]

If SSM is overrated, then that has to mean delahoja is a fraud. SS beat him twice, and was smaller than hoja. delahoja said he'd fight the winner of the COTTO MARGARITO fight. He never did. While SSM fought BOTH. Lost to one and almost killed the other. SSM OVERRATED??? Think again Haters!!!

You obviously dont get the point.

[MOTHER DUCKER]

He beat Oscar x 2, Vargas x 2 and Margarito hardly lost all his big fights..

At the time i wouldn't consider Mosley/Winky a big fight either

[S IP U IR S xII]

Shane is a hall of famer with a hall of fame career.

people let fighters late fights swing their opinion too much.

Shane was SCARY in his prime

Im not doing that at all. I agree hes a HOF. I am calling out the inconsistencies of so many with the biased logic, and limited objectiveness.

[S IP U IR S xII]

He beat Oscar x 2, Vargas x 2 and Margarito hardly lost all his big fights..

At the time i wouldn't consider Mosley/Winky a big fight either

Oscar KO'ed Vargas first, Winky was a victim of circumstance when it came to popularity, and Shane really lost that rematch (and he was juicing). I give him full credit for Margs 100% though. He showed his heart and determination. Like i said, i think Shane is a HOF still, but im calling out the people who dont call it the same way for every fighter.

[MidnightSpecial]

Im not doing that at all. I agree hes a HOF. I am calling out the inconsistencies of so many with the biased logic, and limited objectiveness.

dude its NSB

3/4 of the posters know jack shit about real boxing

the one place where ducking can be written off as "vacation"