If Mosely was at his Prime fighting Floyd who would have won?

[treason1]

prime kfc wouldve beat mosley.

[120]

Floyd Still. Shane would have never been able to beat floyd in a boxing match. that was his mistake

[joelab75]

if Mosley was in his peak he would have handed Mayweather his first official lost. Mosley rocked Floyd and almost knock him down. think about Shane 5 yrs ago and Shane would have followed it thru after he hurt Mayweather. only a fool would say Mosley wouldnt have a chance prime for prime. if you guys think Mosley is still in his prime or close to his prime you are a fool.

[BoxerDood]

if Mosley was in his peak he would have handed Mayweather his first official lost. Mosley rocked Floyd and almost knock him down. think about Shane 5 yrs ago and Shane would have followed it thru after he hurt Mayweather. only a fool would say Mosley wouldnt have a chance prime for prime. if you guys think Mosley is still in his prime or close to his prime you are a fool.

And I could easily say a prime Mayweather could box circles around him too.

[King Koopa]

It would be more competitive if they fought at 135...

[letsgobrady]

During there fight Mosely was an old man in there, he needed a cane.. Too old, no stamina mouth already opened in the 4th round. He couldn't keep up, he had no stamina. He is just to old for an almost 39 year old fighter. It just shows people where fooled to believing he still has it.

As Larry Merchant pointed out in an interview, fighters who are past there prime will still create the illusion that they are good when faced with a slow fighter (Margarito), But if faced with a fast younger fighter the reality takes over and it usually shows the real picture that past there prime fighters can't compete with someone faster.

We all know Power is the last one that goes out from an old fighter, that's why he still caught floyd with a devastating right. It's just that he was too slow to compete with Floyd's youth.

If it was a young primed mosely who fought Floyd. Floyd would have his 2nd loss already ( castillo his first loss ). Mosely would have finished him of for sure. He just wasn't able to finish him off coz lets face it speed vs speed, a younger fighter will most likely have more to offer.

First of all you guys say Mosely ain't a prune coz he is still good for a almost 39 year old fighting May, but what more if Mosely was in his prime fighting Floyd.. Mosely wasn't competing at the highest level at age 38.

If Mosely was at his prime and landed that big bombs that buckled Floyd twice. It is not hard to believe that Mosely could have followed up and ended the fight.

I don't even think he would have to even follow threw with more punches. If a 38 year old mosely can buckle Floyd what more if that bomb that landed on Floyd was from a prime mosely. Lights out for sure.

PBF got caught by an old 38 year old Mosely. A faster stronger Mosely would have landed it much heavier if it was at his prime. I know Floyd has the ability to adjust. But what will he have to adjust from if Mosely gets that hard right bomb in there. It's over man. Floyd will go to lala land. If Floyd is still standing. He will finish him of with a barrage of punches. Ain't rocket science. Floyd has nothing to adjust coz he will be sleeping real good.

Sometimes boxing is brute force. 1 punch is all it takes to turn a tide.

So I'm making this poll.

Who wins prime vs prime.

Note: Mistext on poll question: I meant if Mosely "was" at his prime fighting floyd who wins?

i think floyd would still win.there is one point in the fight where shane tells ****m he's to smart,thats crazy

[LIGHTYEAR]

i dont know if any of you belong to boxing club but one the 1st things the trainer tells you that in everyfighter the last thing to go is your power, shane has his power.

he sat down on both of punches with weight especially the first one & he said this himself
and before the fight his trainer Naazim said shane can knock out farm animals yada yada yada.

the question is how many fighters could've of took those shots, not go down and by the end of the round be back in control? (check the tape)

[Gorilla Dogs]

bait thread. bait thread

[joelab75]

And I could easily say a prime Mayweather could box circles around him too.

so what you're saying was Mayweather is not in his prime anymore? i dont buy that. if you go by Floyd's age it means Mosley's prime would have been 6 yrs ago. so Mosley who lost to Floyd was 6 yrs removed from his prime. and still rocked him and almost knock him down.

[championgee]

SPOON23 IS A JOKE, you posted over 90 threads about Mayweather, nothing else. You are crazy about Mayweather and don't even no it. You love him and thats why he's all you talk about. I thought I was a MAYWEATHER DIE HARD FAN, BUT YOU GOT ME BEAT. You wish Pacquiao had the skill to beat Mayweather but he does'nt. Pacman could'nt beat MAYWEATHER NO mATTER WHAT PEDS HES ON. I understand MAYWEATHER WANTS TO KO HIM IN DRAMATIC FASHION. Keeping PACQUIAO OFF DRUGS WILL MAKE IT EVEN EASIER, LOL