Is Floyd Mayweather Jr A ''All Time Great''

[pocket_rockets]

i dont get this. boxing has a history deeper that most sports including basketball, baseball and football and all of those sports pretty much consider atgs from the top 50-100 athletes. so why wouldnt boxing do the same? thats what atg has always meant to me.

I voted NO! Can I take it back? Didn't know was supposed to be top 100 ATG, thought it was only top 40 or something LOL! He barely makes the top 100 though.

Unless he formally calls out Pac and beat him, he'll just be remember as Floyd "take the test" Mayweather. The fighter with ridiculous boxing skills but lacks the balls!

[evil-lad]

just outside of it. he couldve made in my list but he definitely wasted the last couple of years with fights i did not want to see and fights he avoided like the plague. neck to neck with joe calazaghe.

[LoadedWraps]

Is the sky blue? Is the Earth round?

Anyone who doesn't have him in the top 10 without question should never be allowed to post in any boxing forum, ever again. Ever.
It's not even debatable. Is there some competition being held for the worst threads ever? I have seen 3 over the last 24 hours that are clear contenders.

[puga]

ive never really seen / heard of a boxing historian say floyd is an all time great......

[evil-lad]

Is the sky blue? Is the Earth round?

Anyone who doesn't have him in the top 10 without question should never be allowed to post in any boxing forum, ever. Again.
It's not even debatable. Is there some competition being held for the worst threads ever? I have seen 3 over the last 24 hours that are clear contenders.

LOL at this clown. floyd aint even top 25 you casual boxing fan.

[illwill112]

@ Loadedwraps The sky is blue and earth is round but May is still ducking. You should fix your sig too. When people say Mayweather, they say the guy who is scared to fight Pac man.

[FeFist]

I often hear he is supposed to be one. But i have to admit when i watch him fight, he dont seem to be a great fighter to me. Elusive of course. But i keep thinking if all one wants is to not get hit, i think anyone could look and fight like him.

Lol, it seems as though you've been spewing **** for some time.

[LoadedWraps]

LOL at this clown. floyd aint even top 25 you casual boxing fan.

Top 5 actually. You must be a casual fan, you couldn't name me 20 fighters even debatable greater than Floyd, and if Manny is anywhere in your top 50, you lose any credibility you might have had.

[evil-lad]

Top 5 actually. You must be a casual fan, you couldn't name me 20 fighters even debatable greater than Floyd, and if Manny is anywhere in your top 50, you lose any credibility you might have had.

LOL at this clown. . this is the reason why *****s are perceived as ignorant wanna be ****** thugs. LOL.

[puga]

if floyd was an all time great, he'd be right next to dela hoya....