Is Floyd Mayweather Jr A ''All Time Great''

[Syf]

Of course...

................

[Gorilla Dogs]

no point in talking with floyd haters....

i hear ya larry. lol

[Spacey1991]

Yes but he could be a much bigger ATG if he really wanted to.

[Frank Ducketts]

These are most of the alts of many of PAc's fans lol. Remember them lol...

alonsomosely, amayseng, andrew14, Brooklyn Rican, canflip, carlosfromsc1, Cherry Picker, CungLe, DGKallday, **** Buffman, edgarg, el salsalero, Everlast2900, Fitefreak, gatagata, hanzoh74, hugh grant, hypodermical, JmH Reborn, Joe1blow, joelab75, LeeVanCleef, lfc19titles, mani1, Megamasterking, minasyan, ModernTalking, Mr Burns, NesNY, PR13, Puya, qwerty07, rdr02000, Reggie Miller, Rico1965, rocky_balboa23, setza, Siren 666, Southpaw Stinger, T.McGrady, trainhard_187, TRAV1$, van118, wicked left hoo, _original_

[Southpaw Stinger]

These are most of the alts of many of PAc's fans lol. Remember them lol...

alonsomosely, amayseng, andrew14, Brooklyn Rican, canflip, carlosfromsc1, Cherry Picker, CungLe, DGKallday, **** Buffman, edgarg, el salsalero, Everlast2900, Fitefreak, gatagata, hanzoh74, hugh grant, hypodermical, JmH Reborn, Joe1blow, joelab75, LeeVanCleef, lfc19titles, mani1, Megamasterking, minasyan, ModernTalking, Mr Burns, NesNY, PR13, Puya, qwerty07, rdr02000, Reggie Miller, Rico1965, rocky_balboa23, setza, Siren 666, Southpaw Stinger, T.McGrady, trainhard_187, TRAV1$, van118, wicked left hoo, _original_

Pac's no atg either.

Floyd's a ducker, Pac's a juicer. Forget them both and watch George Groves. He's the truth.

[1nonlymre]

I voted no. This is a very subjective answer, of course, and it's one that reflects my views of Floyd as of 8/11/2010 at 8:10 a.m. Pacific Time.

Seems that the past few years have been entertaining to see him show his technical prowse...unfortunately, the choice of opponent doesn't led him to a greater status.

Sometimes, a boxer is fighting during a time when the best out there just aren't that great, and that sucks for the boxer's legacy and statement of being a GOAT.

However, this hasn't been so for Floyd. The better choices of opponents were out there and he didn't always go that route in the past few years. That's why i vote the way i do.

I don't care how much money he makes, don't care how good he was in the ring. I say 'was' because he showed how good he was against good opponents in lower classes. However, in WW, he hasn't faced the publicly perceived best, and that's important, because GOAT is based on public perception.

Sure, wars get you there. But if Floyd can do it without getting hit, he's a shoe-in. He just has to do it against the best. That is his flaw.

[S.J. II]

I often hear he is supposed to be one. But i have to admit when i watch him fight, he dont seem to be a great fighter to me. Elusive of course. But i keep thinking if all one wants is to not get hit, i think anyone could look and fight like him.

[SirTomJones]

No, people are too ******* with the term ATG.

[Kagami Taiga]

No, people are too ******* with the term ATG.

i dont get this. boxing has a history deeper that most sports including basketball, baseball and football and all of those sports pretty much consider atgs from the top 50-100 athletes. so why wouldnt boxing do the same? thats what atg has always meant to me.

[x3_bazooka_x3]

6 time world champion in 5 different weight classes warrants that I'd think.

Forget his career at the higher weights at lightweight, yes, what he has done for the sport financially at the higher weights I would say in terms of Business yes.