Andre Berto vs Joshua Clottey

[THE REED]

I don't know if this 2010 Quintana could beat Judah. Seeing that he has no punch resistance at all.

He has a **** ton more heart, though.

Quintana would put it on Judah.

Judah doesn't want to see any kind of pressure at this point.

He needs to stay at JR WW, where I can at least be a little excited for him.

[Dick Buffman]

Quintana held his own for a few... and then he got hammered.

Either way... Quintana ****s Judah.

Quintana is a decent boxer with the most fragile body and chin in boxing.

Not exactly hard to hurt the guy. Berto was getting outboxed easily and hurt, then he landed a big punch and what a shock, Quintana was hurt.

Weak win anyway you slice it.

[THE REED]

Quintana is a decent boxer with the most fragile body and chin in boxing.

Not exactly hard to hurt the guy. Berto was getting outboxed easily and hurt, then he landed a big punch and what a shock, Quintana was hurt.

Weak win anyway you slice it.

Definitely a good win.

[street bully]

How do you say Clottey won in so many eyes?

Because of a boxingscene poll?

Cotto won the fight... because when Clottey needed to win tthe important championship rounds... he chased Cotto around with a smile on his face as Cotto put his work in.

He didn't win the rounds he needed to win, to win the fight... as **** usual.

The rounds Clottey won were a helluva lot more convincing. The only lopsided round Cotto had was after Clottey stayed in a corner while he shook off a hurt knee.

Also boxingscene is a place for boxing fans. I think the opinions of hardcore fight fans holds merit.

[gqjohnb]

I thought the cut due to accidental headbutt putting cotto in tentative running mode was enough to get Clottey a slight edge in that fight though. Although i wasn't mad at the end result because Clottey didn't go get him and because Cotto could have just let it go to the cards early and won that way. Of course fighters usually are hesitant to put fights in the judges hands like that but still.

[Dick Buffman]

Definitely a good win.

Ok Horus Jr.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

I thought the cut due to accidental headbutt putting cotto in tentative running mode was enough to get Clottey a slight edge in that fight though. Although i wasn't mad at the end result because Clottey didn't go get him and because Cotto could have just let it go to the cards early and won that way. Of course fighters usually are hesitant to put fights in the judges hands like that but still.

Clottey GAVE that fight away IMO...especially in the 12th when he didnt do **** with the fight in the balance

[THE REED]

The rounds Clottey won were a helluva lot more convincing. The only lopsided round Cotto had was after Clottey stayed in a corner while he shook off a hurt knee.

Also boxingscene is a place for boxing fans. I think the opinions of hardcore fight fans holds merit.

Nah...

It doesn't matter.

Clottey lost the fight, close but clearly.

As I was LOOKING for a way to say Clottey won..

But he didn't.

He lost.

And that's the end of it.



Berto and Clottey get in that ring.

Clottey loses.

You can analyze it all you want, and say this guy beat that guy.. or this guy had close fights but LOST THEM ALL and so on and so forth.

It won't matter.

Clottey loses.

[THE REED]

Ok Horus Jr.

Yeah ****in right

[IMDAZED]

Clottey doesn't have the power to trouble Berto too much. Nor does he have the heart. Berto close decision in another fight Clottey coulda, shoulda, woulda.