Is it fair for a 6'3 tall man to fight a 5'6 man because they're the same weight?

[DrewWoodside]

Stamos won't, He knows he has a chance to shine in a good comedy with me being the main actor.

Stamos will be lucky to play second fiddle to Vinny Chase's brother.. Umm, anyway back to the topic.. It won't be fair for Punisher!: http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=408729

[THE REED]

What fight were you watching? Williams came in at 166 for the fight against Martinez.

Cotto never weighed that much in any of his bouts

READ WHat I said.

I bet you Cotto comes in heavier as a welterweight than Williams did AS a welterweight.

[THE REED]

Williams came in to the ring at 165 against Margarito (who came in at 162), a fight that was contested at the 147 limit.

Yes you are correct about the Margarito fight.

[krispy kreme]

If Williams can make the weight there should not be any issues.

Boxing is about weight classes.

[SirTomJones]

No one moans really about Tommy Hearns.

I know he was shorter than Williams and fought at higher weight divisions but he was still very tall for his weight class.

[THE REED]

Either way.. if you can make the weight.. that's the end of it.

His ONLY loss came to a 5 8 southpaw welterweight..

[Championart]

Boxing doesn't have a height class so whats the problem?

[Wreckless]

READ WHat I said.

I bet you Cotto comes in heavier as a welterweight than Williams did AS a welterweight.

There has been occasions where Williams weighed in in the 160s fight night for WW fights. An average Williams weighs more than Cotto.

[krispy kreme]

Either way.. if you can make the weight.. that's the end of it.

His ONLY loss came to a 5 8 southpaw welterweight..

I thought Quintana is a little closer to 5'10 or at least 5'9 1/2?

[SirTomJones]

Either way.. if you can make the weight.. that's the end of it.

His ONLY loss came to a 5 8 southpaw welterweight..

pretty much sums up all that needs to be said.