Comments Thread For: Merchant: Mayweather-Pacquiao, Klitschko-Haye Top List

[Singleton]

No fight will be made with all the excuses coming out from these fighters. They should have to STFU and fight.

[Bengali Boxer]

the 5 fights that i want to see are
1. mayweather vs martinez (for the 160 middleweight wbc lineal title)
2. mayweather vs pacquiao
3. haye vs wlad
4. khan vs maidana
5. abraham vs ward

[Singleton]

Pac vs May is close to a done deal. I think they will announce the fight in the coming weeks. Props to the promoters.

[crack_head25]

why do u guys arguing with catchwieghts?
for god sake!!!!! catchwieght or not,its still the same

for example WW limit is 141-147 .so even if they meet at 145 weight ,its still a WW

u guys need to remember when manny fought oscar, he wiegh 142 lbs oscar wiegh 147 but its still a WW match...god!!

[jrosales13]

why do u guys arguing with catchwieghts?
for god sake!!!!! catchwieght or not,its still the same

for example WW limit is 141-147 .so even if they meet at 145 weight ,its still a WW

u guys need to remember when manny fought oscar, he wiegh 142 lbs oscar wiegh 147 but its still a WW match...god!!

Actually it was 145.

[jrosales13]

You can had Manny to this list as well. How many have he fought in their prime and at their weight? Delahoya=No (Plus he was weight-drained and a part time fighter,) Cotto=No (weight-drained and lost his last few fights with one debatable win) Diaz=No (He was the weakest link in his division, plus he was very limited skillwise) Hatton=No (He fought face-first and was koed by Mayweather which took his confidence away but it probably didn't matter in Hatton's case) Marquez=YES (And everybody saw the difference and that's why Marquez will never get a third chance) Barrera=No (Old and been through too many wars Morales=No (same reason as Barrera; old and been through too many wars)!! My take on Manny Pacquiao is that he really is a good fighter but far from great. Just been fed too many give mes. in my personal opinion!!!

Of course you can. it is very very hard for fighters to fight A listers in their prime at their best weight.

You could only find a few at fighters resume's.

And, BTW the first Barrera fight, Barrera was in his absolute prime.

[crack_head25]

Actually it was 145.

haha its 141 dude....if its 145 then manny is not a WW when he fought oscar?

[jrosales13]

haha its 141 dude....if its 145 then manny is not a WW when he fought oscar?

What? You said Oscar weight-in at 147. I am saying no, he weight-in at 145 and Pac was at 142(which you was correct about). I was correcting you on Oscar weight for that fight.

[crack_head25]

What? You said Oscar weight-in at 147. I am saying no, he weight-in at 145 and Pac was at 142(which you was correct about). I was correcting you on Oscar weight for that fight.

aww...sorry my bad

[Singleton]

why do u guys arguing with catchwieghts?
for god sake!!!!! catchwieght or not,its still the same

for example WW limit is 141-147 .so even if they meet at 145 weight ,its still a WW

u guys need to remember when manny fought oscar, he wiegh 142 lbs oscar wiegh 147 but its still a WW match...god!!

A lot of people here misunderstood the meaning of catch weight and they will discredit the fighter because of that.