Top 100 ATG's

[Bhopreign]

WTF are you talking about? JCC is a great fighter. I don't think he is greater than Whitaker but he is a true ATG fighter.

Yes I agree he's a great fighter, I said so great. Pernell is greater. But again what do you quantify as ATG?

[MONEYMAY-]

Pernell may have been the better all around boxer....but he doesn't even come close to having the same ATG career than JCC had, Which in my mind makes him be higher than pernell.

[ChampBox@PR]

lol no bitching, because of Calzaghe being in it? This is a surprise

[ChampBox@PR]

Pernell may have been the better all around boxer....but he doesn't even come close to having the same ATG career than JCC had, Which in my mind makes him be higher than pernell.

Talking about biasness!!

[RubenSonny]

marciano>calzaghe

[Bhopreign]

JC is one of the greatest fighters of all time and its not just 1 win, no 1 win makes you great. His greatness has to do with his longevity as a world class fighter in the sport.

Didnt say he wasnt great but he's hyped up IMO more than he should be.

[ChampBox@PR]

marciano>calzaghe

What?????

[Bhopreign]

Pernell may have been the better all around boxer....but he doesn't even come close to having the same ATG career than JCC had, Which in my mind makes him be higher than pernell.

Thats preposteruous.

[Dick Buffman]

Mayweather belongs nowhere near that list.

His best win? A 38 year old no trigger pulling Shane Mosley??



GTFO..

I'd put Cotto in there before Mayweather. At least Cotto's fought everyone.

[RubenSonny]

What?????

can you present an argument as to why calzaghes greater? btw i think they are both great fighters.