Top 100 ATG's

[Shadows]

So just because I'm pro-*********** I have to be an Anti-Semite? pathetic really

Just pointing something out.

[JAB5239]

No reason at all. There have been some Great ***ish fighters indeed. I'm just pointing out you have 2 ***s in your Top 10. That is all.

As I already pointed out, this was a quick list off the top of my head. Leonard and Ross are however two of histories greatest fighters whether one thinks they should be in the top 10 or not. Interesting that you would pick the 2 ***ish fighters to comment on though, especially when you've called me a Zionist in the past for thinking so highly of Ross. Im just saying.

[Fighting Marine]

As I already pointed out, this was a quick list off the top of my head. Leonard and Ross are however two of histories greatest fighters whether one thinks they should be in the top 10 or not. Interesting that you would pick the 2 ***ish fighters to comment on though, especially when you've called me a Zionist in the past for thinking so highly of Ross. Im just saying.

Well you are entitled to your opinion. I just don't rank ***ish fighters as high as you is all I'm stating.

I also disagree with your stance that Heavyweights cannot be ranked as high as fighters who have fought in multiple weight classes. Louis and Ali both fought in golden eras of Heavyweight boxing and fought multiple ATG's.

[JAB5239]

Well you are entitled to your opinion. I just don't rank ***ish fighters as high as you is all I'm stating.

Considering their accomplishments and resumes, why not?

[RubenSonny]

Anybody can criticize someone else's list. It takes balls to criticize a list and then put your own out there for everybody else to criticize. Notice how he said he didn't know enough about boxing history to make his own list? How can you frown upon anyone else if you don't have the knowledge yourself? See what Im saying?

if you dont compose your own list it doesnt mean you dont have the right to disagree or question someone elses list.

[Fighting Marine]

Considering their accomplishments and resumes, why not?

why not? there are many more fighters who have achieved more and have more depth in their resumes.

[Fighting Marine]

if you dont compose your own list it doesnt mean you dont have the right to disagree or question someone elses list.

I agree........

[RubenSonny]

Hagler is severly overrated!



I already said I use his annd ESPN's Top 50 as a basis

so why do you rank calzaghe higher than marciano?

[JAB5239]

if you dont compose your own list it doesnt mean you dont have the right to disagree or question someone elses list.

Ok, fair enough. But if you don't know what you're talking about concerning boxing history (as Bhopreign admitted) it sure makes you look like an ******* to criticize something you don't know about. Wouldn't you agree?

[JAB5239]

why not? there are many more fighters who have achieved more and have more depth in their resumes.

Many? Go ahead and name them.