Does Cotto make it back on your P4P List??

[jrosales13]

In other words your list is laughable.

Wasn't Dirrell #7 on your list?

[murmagic]

he should get back on it imo

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Wasn't Dirrell #7 on your list?

I dont remember where exactly. I took him off. I always counted the Froch fight as a win which wasnt fair to Froch.

Gun to my head Dirrell is one of the best 10 fighters in the world.

[boxaholic]

No Yuri is not a real champ. I appreciated his toughness though. When Miguel beats a top guy at 154 he will easily be mentioned in the top 10. Now he is top 15.

[theplayerpimp]

PWill is the best in the sport... are you serious? Cotto probably got his less in this fight than Williams did against Cintron. You can't even talk about Cotto's defense and then bring up Paul Williams. I mean at least Cotto keeps his hands up, Williams is so concerned about throwing a punch he doesn't even try to defend. Also who has he beaten to even get him in the top 10? Getting a robbery and beating Margarito are his two biggest wins, Cotto resume wipes the floor with PWill's. I'm not saying Cotto should be anyone's top 10, but to say PWill is the best in boxing when he hasn't even beaten a guy ranked in the P4P best ever.

Yea the same margarito who beat the crap out of cotto? And having a win over the lineal middle weight champion of the world is more than cotto has beat. He also has wright cintron and every body he has been in the ring with. Not like cotto in his two most important fights he got destroyed

[Hallaqsillaq]

No Yuri is not a real champ. I appreciated his toughness though. When Miguel beats a top guy at 154 he will easily be mentioned in the top 10. Now he is top 15.

He beat the guy who beat the guy.

He was a champ, no power in his fists (though he was clocking an old Santos), with a not-so-fan-friendly style, but he was champ. It's not fair to him or Cotto to be downplaying either of them.

[Hallaqsillaq]

Yea the same margarito who beat the crap out of cotto? And having a win over the lineal middle weight champion of the world is more than cotto has beat. He also has wright cintron and every body he has been in the ring with. Not like cotto in his two most important fights he got destroyed

Pwill lost to both Sergio (that was a gift decision) and Cintron, whom was easily outboxing him. I think he's peaked. Glass-jaw Quintana gave him a boxing clinic (remember Quintana is an older fighter, even in the rematch where he got KO'd)...

Cotto just beat the guy who beat the guy (Margarito) twice.

[Heeb]

You could make an argument for putting him on the lower end of the top 10. The only fighters I think would beat him at 154 and Pwill and Martinez who are P4P material themselves.

[Iceta Lives]

Cotto is not a top ten P4P fighter and his fight with Clottey who is an average fighter himself proves that. A lot of people think Cotto should've lost that fight.

[Weebler I]

Cotto never left the PFP list, he has lost one fight in his entire career, to the greatest fighter of the era (in any weight).