Greater Fighter, Roy Jones Jr Or Floyd Mayweather Jr?

[Southpaw Great]

Who in YOUR OPINION should rank higher on a ATG List and why?

[da chosen 1]

Mayweather

[osko0ler]

Mayweather. Hes undefeated has faced more quality opponents. He will go down as the best fighter in our generation hands down.

[Carpe Diem]

Jones....Floyd kind of reminded of Jones in a less explosive sort of way..They have the same kind of movement gestures, ect...

[Joeyzagz]

Who in YOUR OPINION should rank higher on a ATG List and why?

TOO early to judge, but Mayweather right now is where Roy was in 2003.

Martinez is Floyds John Ruiz


Pacquiao is Floyds Antonio Tarver

Mayweather needs to make the smart decision and face the guy in his own weight class first(pacman), and save the bigger guy for later.

Dont make the same mistake Roy Jones made by moving up, then coming down in weight to face a dangerous guy.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Roy Jones. But Mayweather's career isn't over.

[etlux]

I think Mayweather has fought the better competition relatively speaking but I'd have to examine both of their careers.

Plus Jones has lost and been KTFO a bunch of times. No matter what you think of that, if Mayweather retires undefeated that will be a big knock against Jones in comparison to Mayweather however we have yet to see how Mayweather does at the tail end of his career and how he steps up teh competition.

[champ007]

It depends how good Mayweather looks once he starts losing. Close decisions vs crawling on the ground looking for a mouthpiece.
Roy has has already spoken.(still ATG)

[TheKza]

Mayweather the greater boxer.

[Dorian]

Mayweather because he fought against tougher opposition..