Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[BillyBoxing]

I agree with Floyd being back at number one.

On the whole, the rankings are pretty solid. I can't really complain about the fighters chosen, though I might change some of their places in the rankings.

I would put Wlad Klit in here,you will tell me who are Chambers and Chagaev.

I would answer for Bradley's case who are ****in Peterson and ****in Holt?What has down this thailandese fighter in the 9th spot??
The Klits are murking contenders World champs for YEARS easy without loosing a round and they can't smell the TOP 10.

They are top 5 in boxrec's ranks.

[leemoorcroft]

no way floyd should be number 1 pacs been fighting all the time for years mayweathers had two fights since 07 and then had one fight in a year pacs fought some of the same guys and pacs looked way beter doin it until they meeet an mayweather wins hes behin in my eyes

[Shabba Rank$]

Right where Floyd deserves to be...

[VallaeBoy]

pathetic. manny faced two big prime welterweights.

Nothing was prime about Josh clottey.....who you fooling

[bojangles1987]

there was nothing impressive about the clottey fight, it played out exactly how evryone thought it would when the fight was first announced and ou seem to forget that all the clean punches in that fight were by clottey

Come on, no one had ever cleanly beaten Clottey, ever, and Pac shut him out. It was impressive. And don't act like Pacquiao didn't land really good punches, he was smashing Clottey's body.

[mikemurni]

ESPN, Ring, Maxboxing, Secondsout had Pac remaining as #1. BScene, Yahoo, Sweet Science (Ron Borges), and perhaps ESB had Mayweather as #1. The media are split on who is the #1 P4P fighters. But the consensus and recognized body, which is the Ring, which ranks this fighters still recognized Pac as no.1. The fact is that both fighters are evenly contesting the slot. It depends on what they do next which will determine the outcome of who would be ranked higher. And please dont say that the fans decides, its more like each other fighter's fans who are concluding that their fighter is number 1.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Come on, no one had ever cleanly beaten Clottey, ever, and Pac shut him out. It was impressive. And don't act like Pacquiao didn't land really good punches, he was smashing Clottey's body.

It was impressive that Clottey was scared. It wasnt a masterful performance though which really isnt Pacs fault. Clottey is an avergae fighter he proved that. HBO even dropped him.

[jltsmae]

Floyd was #1 before he retired Pacquiao NEVER beat Floyd so I don't understand the argument that Pac is #1 until he loses. You guys talk about JMM and Shane Mosley's age. Well if they are soo old and past their prime why did Pacquiao avoid a 3rd fight with Marquez and duck Mosley in front of the whole world?

Just curious if Floyd beat the the previous # 1 before him to become # 1.

I would like to see Pac-JMM III but many (especially the judges of the fight)have thought that Pac already beat JMM, so why can't we just respect them.

Personally, I don't think Manny ducked Shane (especially after what happened last Saturday), it was Roach who think Shane is too good for Manny at that time. I think Manny will still fight Shane if he has to.

[VallaeBoy]

Floyd clowned the JMM while Manny had a life and death struggle with him. Floyd comfortably beat Oscar and Ricky while Manny took the scraps. Floyd clowned Shane while Manny refused to fight him at 140 or 147. Floyd has no flaws in the ring and Manny has no idea what the word defense means.......nuff said.

[PH|L]

Ring Magazine still has Pacquiao as numero uno

sorry folks. better luck next time. Floyd still needs to get better to surpass the Pacman.