Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[The Guru_]

haha ****** boxingscene top 10 means nothing, Mannys still P4P king with the ring.

[Smooth Criminal]

Mayweather p4p1.

He always was!

[screwhead1]

so what list is pac still number 1 on?

[Tuggers1986]

Until Pacquiao loses he hold the top spot.

So if Pacquiao fought 3 bums but Mayweather fought and beat Berto, Cotto and Williams then Pacquiao is still number 1?

Your logic is wrong. Its who people think the best fighter is at any given weight. You don't stay on the top just because you're winning. You get to the top because of HOW you're winning

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Good job Cliff.

1. Floyd
2. Pac
3. Williams
4. Dawson
5. Martinez
6. Marquez
7. Montiel
8. Bradley
9. Wonjongkam
10. Calderon




Good list.

[GoogleMe]

Pac just kept the seat warm.

[ryedog87]

pathetic. manny faced two big prime welterweights. floyd faced a blown up old featherweight and a gassed 39 year old mosley. and you rate him number 1? man you guys make me laugh

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

pathetic. manny faced two big prime welterweights. floyd faced a blown up old featherweight and a gassed 39 year old mosley. and you rate him number 1? man you guys make me laugh

Get out Pacs butt for a second.

[jltsmae]

PLUS, Mosley KO'd
Margarito, who KO'd an UNDEFEATED Cotto and took his title and
Mosley took the title from Margarito.

So, Marga's KO over Cotto (POSSIBLY WITH PLASTER) is better than the accused PED user (without evidence) Manny's KO over Cotto? I thought you are in favor of a level playing field but seems like you are PATRONISING a proven PLASTER user Marga's win over Cotto.

Can you imagine if Marga was not found with plaster during his Shane match. Marga could have done to Shane what he did to Cotto you know.

Shane has admitted taking Peds, so those 39 KO's could be with PEDS, who knows. And look what happen to Shane with his fight with Cotto and Floyd, probably without PEDS, I think you know what happen, don't you?

[Ray*]

i still think Pac deserves #1 but i won't complain that floyd is now #1. they are so close to eachother that you could argue either way!

Thats the way i feel too, Would love to see them two settling it in the ring once and for all, Its great that both are in around the same weight class so they can prove it by fighting each other.