Better Resume, Shane or Floyd?

[daggum]

He was a slam dunk style wise? No one thought Floyd would win that fight.

You know that Oscar beat Vargas right?

He also did not go life and death Forbes man...lol. He arguably shut him out. That fight was also a year later at 150 Pounds.

no one thought mayweather would beat corales? revising history sounds fun. can you revise history so floyd didn't duck anyone and guys like phillip ndou and henry bruseles were the top challengers of his time.

[savorduhflavor]

Negative savor.

Corrales was a slam dunk for floyd style wise. He never turned out to be more than a slugger. Vernon was all the way wrong for Shane, yet shane still fought him and had worthy efforts. Winky was is and always will be a pfp better fighter than castillo and corralles will ever be.

Floyd gets ,imi,a; credit for that win. I think Shne's wins over Vargas are more impressive than Floyd's win over an oscar that went life and death with forbes right after.

Dude, no way on all accounts. You give Shane more credit for a VERY tough first fight with a shot Vargas, and a KO over a completely shot Vargas than Floyd's win over a plenty game Oscar? That's crazy to me, but we're just gonna have to agree to disagree.

So you give Shane credit for taking fights that, styles wise, were tougher? Corrales was held in just as high regard as Forrest at the time Floyd beat him, but Floyd gets credit taken away cause it was a good style matchup? Come on, that's bull****.

Winky's probably better than both, but Shane lost to him twice, the first fight was pretty one sided too.

Shane was ****** for taking those fights, Winky was supposed to be a tuneup fight for Trinidad. Sorry, but I don't praise Shane for that. Corrales and Castillo were the highest rated fighters in their respective divisions when Floyd fought them....what more did you want from him at that point?

[-GDS-]

Negative savor.

Corrales was a slam dunk for floyd style wise. He never turned out to be more than a slugger. Vernon was all the way wrong for Shane, yet shane still fought him and had worthy efforts. Winky was is and always will be a pfp better fighter than castillo and corralles will ever be.

Floyd gets ,imi,a; credit for that win. I think Shne's wins over Vargas are more impressive than Floyd's win over an oscar that went life and death with forbes right after.

Bullcrap for all the obvious reasons I'm sure you won't acknowledge. Also, Jake LaMotta fought SRR 6 times. Does he have the greatest resume of all time in your opinion?

[savorduhflavor]

no one thought mayweather would beat corales? revising history sounds fun. can you revise history so floyd didn't duck anyone and guys like phillip ndou and henry bruseles were the top challengers of his time.

My man....expert predictions were split about 50/50 for that fight.

I was shocked as well, trust me, but I was proven wrong.

[Walt Liquor]

He was a slam dunk style wise? No one thought Floyd would win that fight.

You know that Oscar beat Vargas right?

He also did not go life and death Forbes man...lol. He arguably shut him out. That fight was also a year later at 150 Pounds.

Yes he was a slam dunk stylewise admittedly in hindsight. there's no way you can't think that corrales wasn't tailor made for floyd after seeing hoew their careers panned out.

I think I do know that burner, but you are so shortsighted that you can't comprehend matchups. Oscar outclassed Vargas waaaaaaay before he fought floyd, like 5-6 years before. shane beat vargas' ass at a weight that he wasn't all that good at a few years before floyd finally cornered dela.

delahoya struggled with steve freaking forbes and you can't tell me otyherwise. i saw it with my own two eyes

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

So Shane can go through 5 weight classes undefeated?

What that have to do with resume????

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Yes he was a slam dunk stylewise admittedly in hindsight. there's no way you can't think that corrales wasn't tailor made for floyd after seeing hoew their careers panned out.

I think I do know that burner, but you are so shortsighted that you can't comprehend matchups. Oscar outclassed Vargas waaaaaaay before he fought floyd, like 5-6 years before. shane beat vargas' ass at a weight that he wasn't all that good at a few years before floyd finally cornered dela.

delahoya struggled with steve freaking forbes and you can't tell me otyherwise. i saw it with my own two eyes

Lets be clear Tito ruined Vargas.

So in hindsight was Cotto, Hatton, oscar and Diaz all tailor made for Pacquiao? Just wondering if this logic applies for all fighters or just Floyd.

ODH was at 150 Pounds a year after he lost to Floyd.

[FloydTBE]

mosley was on steroids for the 2nd hoya fight

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

What that have to do with resume????

Then he doesnt go through Floyds resume undefeated.

[daggum]

My man....expert predictions were split about 50/50 for that fight.

I was shocked as well, trust me, but I was proven wrong.

why are you telling me this tell that fool that said no one thought mayweather would win. lots of people thought he would win but he's trying to lie to make mayweather look better.