Better Resume, Shane or Floyd?

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Shane's depth at 135 is weak????? then you say floyd fought the best at 154? C'mon

There was noone left at 135 for Shane, Floyd fought one over the hill cash cow at 154. That was just bad.

Floyd fought the best at 130-135 (for the most part), 8-10 years ago. Shane fought the best at 147 and 154 FOR THE LAST 8-10 YEARS.

Floyd did not fight the best at 147. Rankings mean jack shi t. It's how good the fighters actually are that counts. Margs was the best at 147.

LMFAO when Floyd entered the WW division Margs was coming of a loss to Santos and a win against Cintron. Other then that he had been fed a steady diet of bums, there is absolutely no evidence to suggest he was the man at 147 around that time.

Margarito was probably even cheating back then.. you saw Williams face after that fight?

[Walt Liquor]

LMFAO when Floyd entered the WW division Margs was coming of a loss to Santos and a win against Cintron. Other then that he had been fed a steady diet of bums, there is absolutely no evidence to suggest he was the man at 147 around that time.

that fight was at 154.

good bye snootz, im not arguing with you because you are dumb and don't know what you are talking about,

[edgarg]

I thikn Corrales was a great win for floyd, he gets more credit for that win than shane gets for his l's vs forrest and wright. BUT shane's win v dela in their first fight was a better win.

I was referring to diego in the "level of comp" discussion. WInky and Vernon were both better fighters than diego, Fighting castillo also took big stones from floyd. i'm not giving him no credit. i think shanes level of comp is better, but that deosn't mean that floyd's sucks.

I don't know if Vargas was shot, but floyd beat an oscar (8-4 I think) that took absolutely no chances and kept trying the same thing over and over the whole fight. Vargas was coming to fight.

Winky may have been a ****** fight, but he was the most avoided fighter in the world and shane showed stones taking that fight.

You are all wrong when you see the Corrales win as "great" for Mayweather. Corrales was dried out like a mummy, had left the division 6-8 months before, was walking around at about 145-150, ............AND, was going to gaol for 2 years right after the fight. He hardly trained, spending all his time in a sweat box, right up to the weigh-in, or, according to his trainer, playing with a Gameboy in his room. He failed to make weight first time, and practically collapsed. In the fight itself, he was going down from weakness mainly, you could see the way he was slowly sinking to the canvas.

The Mayweathers tempted him with a big purse when he was desperate for money, to pay his legal bills. There was a lot of publicity at that time about how "smart" the Mayweather
"BRAINSTRUST" was to bait him with (as Corrales said on a TV interview, which was specifically about his weight problem)

"AN OFFER I COULDN'T REFUSE..............". I became sympathetic towards Corrales after that interview.

[Walt Liquor]

You are all wrong when you see the Corrales win as "great" for Mayweather. Corrales was dried out like a mummy, had left the division 6-8 months before, was walking around at about 145-150, ............AND, was going to gaol for 2 years right after the fight. He hardly trained, spending all his time in a sweat box, right up to the weigh-in, or, according to his trainer, playing with a Gameboy in his room. He failed to make weight first time, and practically collapsed. In the fight itself, he was going down from weakness mainly, you could see the way he was slowly sinking to the canvas.

The Mayweathers tempted him with a big purse when he was desperate for money, to pay his legal bills. There was a lot of publicity at that time about how "smart" the Mayweather
"BRAINSTRUST" was to bait him with (as Corrales said on a TV interview, which was specifically about his weight problem)

"AN OFFER I COULDN'T REFUSE..............". I became sympathetic towards Corrales after that interview.

plus he was about to get locked up...

[-EX-]

Money Mayweather will always be a clown who handpicked his opponents just like Roy.I hope Shane puts him in his place and shuts him up on saturday.

Roy > Mosley

[MOTHER DUCKER]

that fight was at 154.

good bye snootz, im not arguing with you because you are dumb and don't know what you are talking about,

So what if it was at 154 it was a loss.. and he had beaten nobodies before then prior to Cintron, you wont argue cause your a little hating **** so good go away

[CarlosG815]

without question it is Shane Mosley. He has one of the best resumes in the history of the game, and probably the best resume of the last 12 years.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

without question it is Shane Mosley. He has one of the best resumes in the history of the game, and probably the best resume of the last 12 years.

Oscar De LeHoya?

[V.WEBB]

so you're saying he wasn't weight drained for pac then if he was only 3 lbs over?

cotto- nowhere near tailor made, he was looking good until manny fighured him out
hatton- tailor made, however he was fighting at his optimal weight, compared to when floyd made him come up in weight
diaz, obviously talior made.


ya'll like to talk about wieght classes...but that doesn't matter with manny to you

You can't praise Manny for fighting Hatton at 140 then knock Floyd for fighting him at 147.

1) When Floyd tried to fight Hatton at 140, Hatton "wasn't ready".
2) Floyd had just beat Oscar at 154 (150) and he wasn't going to go back down to fight Hatton at 140, so he made him come to his weight class, like Oscar did Floyd, like Hatton did Manny.

[-EX-]

without question it is Shane Mosley. He has one of the best resumes in the history of the game, and probably the best resume of the last 12 years.

Pacquiao and DLH's are better without question...