Better Resume, Shane or Floyd?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Floyd also has titles in 5 weight divisions and is notorious for shutting out opponents. So there's your dominance.

If you take into account HOW they're winning, that can't be denied.

That doesnt have anythng to do with your resume(Who you fought). That goes in the accomplishments category!!

[boxasmash]

Since losses don't count and all, could I fight the Klit. bros, David Haye and Chad Dawson and have a better resume than both these guys?

Losses to those guys isn't really a plus or negative.

[boxasmash]

So wait by this logic Judah has a better resume then Floyd?

Judah never beat a Prime ODLH or Margarito, next.

[dans]

That doesnt have anythng to do with your resume(Who you fought). That goes in the accomplishments category!!

Okay but shutting out opponents does. And so do bad losses by Mosley.

Prime Oscar is better than any of Floyd's wins. But other than that, I don't see how it's Mosley.

[Iceta Lives]

At 147 the last few years I'd say Mosley's resume ****s on Floyd's. Collazo is a good win. If you are talking about what have you done for me lately Mosley's body of work is way more impressive. Mayweather's resume is actually overrated because there are a lot of guys he leaped over. Both Floyd and Mosley leaped over Stevie Johnston though. They however would've beaten him.

[-EX-]

I don't count losses......Mayweather


If u wanna count losses(as in just in who has faced better comp) than Shane edges it...

[Brz_Pugilist]

Mayweather's accomplishments are ridiculous!This guy is a fraud!If he is such a great champion then why didnt he get in the ring with champions during his time.The guy handpicks his opponents and your an ****** if u dont know that by now.I hope Mosley kicks his ass.I do wish that Shane was 33 but maybe he still got something in him.

[dans]

Judah never beat a Prime ODLH or Margarito, next.

IMO beating Castillo and Corrales > Margarito

We can't even really place how good the Marg win was yet cause he's a dirty rat. We should know more soon.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Judah never beat a Prime ODLH or Margarito, next.

Judah:

Spinks
Spinks
Witter
Mayweather
Cotto
Clottey
Kostya

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Okay but shutting out opponents does. And so do bad losses by Mosley.

Prime Oscar is better than any of Floyd's wins. But other than that, I don't see how it's Mosley.

first of all, I never said Mosley(Just to make it clear). And yes shutting your opponents down, do count so Knocking them the **** out wich Mosley pretty much always does!

By the way Margarito is a better win too!!!