Better Resume, Shane or Floyd?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I mean Oscar x2 and Margarito are better wins than anything on Floyd's resume

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Champ I think we may have argued this type thing before.

I think you consider resume "who they've faced", correct? Not who they've beaten or lost to?

For resume I take who they foughy overall. Then I take into account W's and L's and how they won or loss.

[Championart]

Let me ask this, are you guys basing the "resume" on who they fought or who they beat because to be honest with you anyone can fight top fighters and lose. Yes it shows some heart to fight the best but if you your'e losing these fights then whats the sense.

[jri9d0]

I mean Oscar x2 and Margarito are better wins than anything on Floyd's resume

And not to mention they were both natural Welters that Shane has victories over.

[jrosales13]

I think Shane first win over Oscar is better than any win in Floyd career.

However, overall from top to bottom I like Floyd resume better...

[ajohnz]

if you're not considering the fact that mosley lost some of those fights then him. but with wins/losses included mayweather.

[Brz_Pugilist]

This is so laughable.Shane Mosley by more then a mile!Mayweather is such a fraud.He didnt get in the ring with the likes of Vernon Forrest, Winky Wright.He didnt fight De La Hoya in his prime.I am sick of all these Mayweather fans making excuses for this guy who handpicks his opponents!

[savorduhflavor]

I mean Oscar x2 and Margarito are better wins than anything on Floyd's resume

I disagree. He lost to Oscar the 2nd time despite juicing.

Floyd absolutely dominated an undefeated Corrales. He fought a razor thin fight with Castillo(I scored it a draw), immediately rematched him and beat him clear as day.

Undefeated Hatton is a solid win. Oscar at 154 is an underrated win for Floyd IMO.

The Marquez win gets nothing from me.

But Mosley has gotten dominated.....I factor that in to resumes. Some of his losses have been one sided.

[Dick Buffman]

Not even close.

Buttweather hasn't fought anyone since Castillo.

[savorduhflavor]

I think Shane first win over Oscar is better than any win in Floyd career.

However, overall from top to bottom I like Floyd resume better...

I can agree with this definitely. I think Shane's resume, in terms of depth, is kind of overrated. Pretty much cause his run at 135 was underwhelming(not his fault, the comp just wasn't there).