If Floyd beats Mosley, is it better than Pacquiao's win over Cotto?

[TBear]

I don't believe so.. Mosley isn't at the climax of his career and besides a great win against Margarito.. he has looked lack luster as of late. I'm a big fan but I just think he has it anymore.. where as Cotto did.

exactly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[bmoffitt18]

depends on how he beats him

[daggum]

gomez's knockout win over castillo is better than floyd's win over castillo.

[el malo]

I have to say the Cotto win, probably because in a head-to-head matchup he beat Moley and Mosley though a great fighter, is not the fighter he was several years ago.

this.../thread.

[Parody]

Mosley is ranked as the #1 Welterweight and #3 P4P Best fighter in the world.

Cotto lost to Margarito and he was was not the same fighter once he got beaten by a guy who used plaster in his gloves, I felt Clottey beat him too in a very close fight.

The Mosley that will face Floyd > The Cotto that faced Pacquiao in terms of ranking, resume, momentum and the fighter itself. Most people felt Cotto was done after the Margarito fight, but Shane looked very good in demolishing Margarito.

[jrosales13]

Mosley is ranked as the #1 Welterweight and #3 P4P Best fighter in the world.

Cotto lost to Margarito and he was was not the same fighter once he got beaten by a guy who used plaster in his gloves, I felt Clottey beat him too in a very close fight.

The Mosley that will face Floyd > The Cotto that faced Pacquiao in terms of ranking, resume, momentum and the fighter itself. Most people felt Cotto was done after the Margarito fight, but Shane looked very good in demolishing Margarito.

Just out of curiosity what rankings are you going by? Boxingscen? Your rankings?

[AntDawg]

I'm with the minority. Pacquiao's win is better imo since Cotto beat has already beaten Mosley.

[Heeb]

The Cotto that Pacquiao beat wasn't the normal Cotto. Although Shane isn't in his prime he is closer to it than Cotto. Floyd's win is better.

[pasawayako]

Pac's win over cotto is better than the floyd's win over mosley, for a simple fact that cotto beat mosley, mosley's win over margarito is overrated who is just a punching bag and no defense margarito and mosley is almost 40 years old.

[illmaticfighter]

is the cotto that beat shane the same cotto that pacquaio beat???

if the answers is no,then the answer for me is floyd's victory is better.