If floyd beats shane, is it a better win than manny's win against barrera?

[SoldierWarrior]

dude, margartio is a prize fighter. he' knos he needs to concentrate to win his fights, ur excuses for him are dumb, espceially considering he never came out and made any himself. i never get why ppl make excuses for others when they dont offer them up.

Are you hyping Mosley up?

Hype Mosley up when he doesn't beat a one-dimensional fighter who doesn't have bricks in his hands anymore!

[-Spinal-]

No, Barrera was in his prime. Plus Pacquiao was the underdog.

That's how good Floyd is, a former Super Featherweight wins over Sugar Shane Mosley, #1 WW, is not much. A Pacquiao win over Sugar Shane Mosley...Pacquiao can retire with that win and didn't even need Barrera, Marquez or Morales. A win over Mosley is more impressive than a win over those 3 put together(for Pacquiao). But for Mayweather he needs to fight Mosley, Williams, Martinez, Ward, Dawson, Adamek, Wlad.

[Kagami Taiga]

Are you hyping Mosley up?

Hype Mosley up when he doesn't beat a one-dimensional fighter who doesn't have bricks in his hands anymore!

its not about hyping him up, its about giving fighters credit for what they do. no1 in the boxing world feels the way you do, no1 cares how margs felt after he got caught. y make excuses for him to take a legit win away from mosely?
uve been sayin that all across the forum, i finnaly decided to call u out on it.

besides i dnt believe that mosley win is better than barerra bull****. but what ur doin is just silly.

[brick wall]

if floyd can do to shane what pac did to barrera in their 1st fight i'll consider floyd's win better.

[Hannibal Barca]

That's how good Floyd is, a former Super Featherweight wins over Sugar Shane Mosley, #1 WW, is not much. A Pacquiao win over Sugar Shane Mosley...Pacquiao can retire with that win and didn't even need Barrera, Marquez or Morales. A win over Mosley is more impressive than a win over those 3 put together(for Pacquiao). But for Mayweather he needs to fight Mosley, Williams, Martinez, Ward, Dawson, Adamek, Wlad.

Preach. Truer words aren't often spoken.

MAB isn't a better win than Mosely, period.

Btw, there's not a single fighter out there between 140-154 that Floyd wouldn't be favored over. Pac included. Using that as an excuse as to why Pac beating MAB was a better win than a Mosely is faulty at best.

[Pullcounter]

That's how good Floyd is, a former Super Featherweight wins over Sugar Shane Mosley, #1 WW, is not much. A Pacquiao win over Sugar Shane Mosley...Pacquiao can retire with that win and didn't even need Barrera, Marquez or Morales. A win over Mosley is more impressive than a win over those 3 put together(for Pacquiao). But for Mayweather he needs to fight Mosley, Williams, Martinez, Ward, Dawson, Adamek, Wlad.

um... beating only mosley doesn't equal and isn't better than wins over mab, jmm, and morales.

[MidnightBliss]

No way...

Floyd is already an established fighter, and 2nd P4P... hes fighting an old shane.

Pac was an underdog and wasnt established as great boxer yet, he was just a kid with fast hands and a solid straight left. MAB was a legend and he got KTFO.

[| THE KING |]

LOL! people are actually debating this?

[BoxerDood]

I don't know...It would be pretty close, only because of the situation they are in. Everyone thought Barrera was gonna bully Floyd. I'd put an old Shane ahead of a prime Barrera, but the situation was amazing for Pacquiao. That was a huge accomplishment for him, and it was the start of his reign. Before that he was fighting "tricycle men" or whatever he said about Valero. lol

[MOTHER DUCKER]

um... beating only mosley doesn't equal and isn't better than wins over mab, jmm, and morales.

Morales? you mean the Morales beaten by Rahmen prior to fighting Pac by wide Dec and obviously shot in the 3rd? what a joke ROFL how the hell is that a better win the beating the top guy at WW right now?

Barrera is probably a better win right now but it also happens to be Pac's best win to date (the first fight). If Floyd beats Mosley it wont be his best win he has had.