if oscar is an atg..then isnt judah aswell??

[IMDAZED]

Well he wasn't getting much credit from people like you for what I thought was a close, but fairly decisive win in the first fight, so who could blame him?

You can't have it both ways. Pea was sliding, but Oscar should've re matched him. Doesn't make sense.

if he wasn't getting much credit, we wouldn't be having this discussion. Your second paragraph makes no sense. The two aren't in contradiction.

Apparently everyone besides you gave a career LW a lot of credit for hanging in there with an ATG MW.

Good for Duran. Back to Oscar?

[MurderDeathKill]

Where's the TS?

[Jim Jeffries]

Good for Duran. Back to Oscar?

Sure, now that we've established that he deserves credit for some of his "losses," and more even from some of his wins.

[infamous larryx]

damn this thread blew up like this???damn i wasnt even serious..lol

[MurderDeathKill]

damn this thread blew up like this???damn i wasnt even serious..lol

I hope not.

[infamous larryx]

why do people keep saying he beat mosley and tito??last time i checked mosley officially beat him 2 times and tito beat him..you cant make up wins

[AntDawg]

Hmm Lets see....Oscar went from 130 to 160 winning belts and beat good to great names while Judah did what besides being the undisputed champ after all the top welterweights moved up.

[Da Hammer]

Lmao one of the dumbest threads i've ever seen. i **** on oscar a lot but nobody can ever question that he fought one of the best resumes in the history of the sport!!! And he beat Whitaker, Chavez, Vargas, Quartey, Camacho. His losses were all against ATG's as well. Pacquiao, Hopkins, Mosley,Trinidad, Mayweather!!!!! No other fighter in the last 30 years can rival the level of opposition that Oscar faced in his career!!! Some come close but not quite!

Putting Judah and Oscar in the same breath is shameful...

[Mr. Fantastic]

damn this thread blew up like this???damn i wasnt even serious..lol

Because you were trolling.

[Mr. Fantastic]

why do people keep saying he beat mosley and tito??last time i checked mosley officially beat him 2 times and tito beat him..you cant make up wins

The same could be said about his wins vs Whitaker, Quartey right??