My New Top 10 P4P - Thoughts!!!

[Dirk Diggler UK]

He said "shoulda" had a win over Will and Cintron.

Hence my reply:

"Woulda, coulda, shoulda" isnt allowed on Bscene remember?"

Reading comprehension isnt your strong suit huh?

"Woulda shoulda coulda" refers to people giving boxers imaginary wins in fights that have never taken place.

Martinez literally knocked Cintron out in front of our very eyes. So comprehension must not be your strong suit.

[BoxerDood]

Here's my list. Yours was great, so I didn't even have to make a brand new one. I just make a few position adjustments and replaced Cotto.

1.Manny Pacquaio
2.Floyd Mayweather
3.Shane Mosley
4.Paul Willams
5.Sergio Martinez (let's face it, a win over Pavlik and a close fight Williams isn't gonna get you over him. He needs to rematch Williams to pass him)
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7.Ivan Calderon
8.Chad Dawson (Once he fights Pascal and Cloud and fights more frequently, he'll deserve a higher spot)
9.Timothy Bradley (the dude had 140 cleared at one point. These new guys like Khan, Alexander and Ortiz have to answer to him now. A win over Maidana will strengthen his case)
10.Wladimir Klitschko

[DR.ORGYY]

chad dawson over cotto and williams???????????

[egreezy]

How can you have Dirrel and not Froch?


What has Dirrel done? His body of work is garbage. He has only 1 good win. he aint P4P material.


Andre Ward is 2 good wins away from maybe 9 or 10.

Don't pretend Dirrelll didn't make Froch look like a fool in that fight...

and it seems some fighters always just have to do a little more for you to put them in your top p4p. Ward dominated to #1SMW... who at the top level has Cotto ever dominated? Not Judah, not Malignaggi, not Clottey, not Mosley or Margarito...

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Here's my list. Yours was great, so I didn't even have to make a brand new one. I just make a few adjustments.

1.Manny Pacquaio
2.Floyd Mayweather
3.Shane Mosley
4.Paul Willams
5.Sergio Martinez (let's face it, a win over Pavlik and a close fight Williams isn't gonna get you over him. He needs to rematch Williams to pass him)
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7.Ivan Calderon
8.Chad Dawson (Once he fights Pascal and Cloud and fights more frequently, he'll deserve a higher spot)
9.Timothy Bradley
10.Wladimir Klitschko

Very Good List. I just dont rank Williams that high

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Don't pretend Dirrelll didn't make Froch look like a fool in that fight...

and it seems some fighters always just have to do a little more for you to put them in your top p4p. Ward dominated to #1SMW... who at the top level has Cotto ever dominated? Not Judah, not Malignaggi, not Clottey, not Mosley or Margarito...

SO one good win and you automatically gets in?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

How can you have Dirrel and not Froch?


What has Dirrel done? His body of work is garbage. He has only 1 good win. he aint P4P material.


Andre Ward is 2 good wins away from maybe 9 or 10.

Well unlike Williams-Martinez. I dont think Froch-Dirrell was even close. I had Dirrell up 9-3.

Then he dominated AA.

Then you look at Froch and AA two good super middleweights.

Ward still undefeated and absolutely ran through the best `168 pounder at the time is very impressive.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Well unlike Williams-Martinez. I dont think Froch-Dirrell was even close. I had Dirrell up 9-3.
Then he dominated AA.

Then you look at Froch and AA two good super middleweights.

Ward still undefeated and absolutely ran through the best `168 pounder at the time is very impressive.

But I only see a loss for Dirrell on boxrec.

[BoxerDood]

Very Good List. I just dont rank Williams that high

I can understand that. Its very hard to rank him...I just can't get myself to put Martinez ahead of him unless they fight again and he wins. Right now wins over Margo, Quintana, Wright, a close fight with Martinez and soon Cintron SLIGHTLY looks better than wins over Cintron and Pavlik, and a debatable loss to P.Will. Although that Pavlik fight gave Martinez a very good case though.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

SO one good win and you automatically gets in?

Martinez only has one good win.

Over a guy most were calling a bum.