My New Top 10 P4P - Thoughts!!!

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Champ answer me this:

I say Williams is Top 5 based off what hes done right.

You say No and before today you never ranked him in the Top 10.

So how is Martinez ranked Top 5 off one win. But you didnt have Paul ranked at all for beating MARTINEZ?

Martinez won the Williams fight in my eyes. He beat Cintron twice in one fight and beat Pavlik,

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

WTF is Dirrell and Ward doing n there? Please enlight me

I just rank the Kessler and Abe win very high. I think both of them are better then Pavlik who Martinez beat.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I wouldn't have Calderon in there as he has not been impressive as of late really.

I would replace Caldy with the Dragon Chris John and put Wlad up a little higher.

Thanks for the reply, ill take notice!

[SiCaRiO13 Jr]

Why Juanma and Ward????

my bad, I meant Chad Dawson over Ward, ward only has 1 good win against kessler.

I put juanma cause he's a undefeated 2 division champ and has knockouts in all except 1 title fight

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I think People are forgetting Williams win over a Prime Margarito.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I just rank the Kessler and Abe win very high. I think both of them are better then Pavlik who Martinez beat.

How can you have Dirrel and not Froch?


What has Dirrel done? His body of work is garbage. He has only 1 good win. he aint P4P material.


Andre Ward is 2 good wins away from maybe 9 or 10.

[BoxerDood]

floyd hasn't done anything great since 2002 and he's always on the list. if this was the mediocre win list i would put him #1 for sure.

Who said anything about Floyd? You always seem to bring him up out of nowhere. I think putting him as #2 was more of a way to hype a Pacquiao clash, and out of respect for the fact that he was p4p king before he retired, and if he had fought DLH in the rematch, he'd still be p4p king and Pacquiao would still be busy trying to clear 135 and 140. Not saying I agree with Floyd being #2. That's just probably their reason.

But regardless, Cotto has no business there. He hasn't dominated a decent opponent since 2007. Heck, even Andre Be...Okay let me not go too far LOL

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

my bad, I meant Chad Dawson over Ward, ward only has 1 good win against kessler.

I put juanma cause he's a undefeated 2 division champ and has knockouts in all except 1 title fight

Ok, I think Juanma needs a another good 2 good wins to get there.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I think People are forgetting Williams win over a Prime Margarito.

And thats a very good win in a close fight no doubt!! Thats Williams best win!

[jri9d0]

Top 10 P4P
1.Manny Pacquaio
2.Floyd Mayweather
3.Juan Manuel Marquez
4.Shane Mosley
5.Sergio Martinez
6.Ivan Calderon
7.Chad Dawson
8.Mguel Cotto
9.Paul Williams
10.Wladimir Klitschko

No arguments from regarding the list, I say your're pretty dead on the money...