Better fighter at their peak: Miguel Cotto or Fernando Vargas

[Mr. Fantastic]

75% of the people voting for Vargas will do so on the grounds that "Vargas never quit."

There's nothing wrong with voting Vargas, I think it's very close personally, but to take individual performances when we're judging this on talent and skills is just ******ed.

I might as well say "Cotto never got knocked out with one punch, he's better".

I voted for Cotto but I disagree with that. I think its based on his victories vs Quartey & Winky.

[savorduhflavor]

I voted for Cotto but I disagree with that. I think its based on his victories vs Quartey & Winky.

Under normal circumstances I agree, and I don't see anything wrong with picking Vargas.

But we're in nsb....come on now, you're giving most of these people too much credit.

[-Hyperion-]

vargas is underrated.......beating quartey like he did is no joke.....of course we're in nsb...the flavor of the month always wins....

its close...but vargas at his peak had a bit more going for him.....

[shogunn]

Vargas domianted African Quartey, Cotto barely got the win over African Clottey.
Vargas went to War with Mexican-American De La Hoya, Cotto quit against Mexican-American Margarito.

That of course has little to do with the question but the answer is 'Ferocious' Fernando Vargas.

Im not understanding what youre trying to say here, especially when you bring race into this

[gibo]

vargas domianted african quartey, cotto barely got the win over african clottey.
Vargas went to war with mexican-american de la hoya, cotto quit against mexican-american margarito.

That of course has little to do with the question but the answer is 'ferocious' fernando vargas.

cotto got cheated by your mesican-american margarito

[gibo]

VARGAS WAS A SIDE-SHOW.. Cotto was a real champion!!!!!!!! If TITO floored vargas 6 times. Cotto would have put him in the hospital!!! Vargas was a fraud!!!

[Frank Martin]

Vargas. Just the win over Quartey and Winky tops Cotto's resume. I dont think Cotto can beat Winky and Quartey

[Left Banned Tua]

VARGAS WAS A SIDE-SHOW.. Cotto was a real champion!!!!!!!! If TITO floored vargas 6 times. Cotto would have put him in the hospital!!! Vargas was a fraud!!!

ehhhh..........

cotto wouldn't even make it out of 1 round slugging it out with tito.

neither would pacquiao , clottey , mosley.......

[Left Banned Tua]

Vargas. Just the win over Quartey and Winky tops Cotto's resume. I dont think Cotto can beat Winky and Quartey

p4p terms. even if you talk about a 140 version of winky or ike. cotto couldn't beat them.

[KickAzz]

vargas in his prime was better, but cotto never got beat down by tito.