So who is the Best Welterweight?

[oaba09]

Shane is still the lineal champ until somebody beats him but let's be realistic here, he has already lost a lot of step because of his age....

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Mosley

[heat27]

Shane Mosley

[Left Banned Tua]

Manny Pacquiao

Shane Mosley

Floyd Mayweather

right now i'd have to say pacquiao.

how he beat cotto and clottey was impressive.


i'd favor both mosley and mayweather to beat him though even though pacquiao has a good chance to win and i'll be rooting for him against mayweather for sure and possibly even against shane.

[Left Banned Tua]

Shane is still the lineal champ until somebody beats him but let's be realistic here, he has already lost a lot of step because of his age....

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Mosley

shane is not the lineal champ.

[piano man]

#1 Shane Mosley
#2 Floyd Mayweather jr
#3 Manny Pacquiao

that's the way cookies crumble

[Left Banned Tua]

#1 Shane Mosley
#2 Floyd Mayweather jr
#3 Manny Pacquiao

that's the way cookies crumble

welterweight fights of all 3 since 2007:

mosley - collazo win , cotto loss , margarito win
mayweather - hatton win , marquez win
pacquiao - delahoya win , cotto win , clottey win

even if you don't want to count delahoya , pacquiao still comes out on top.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

welterweight fights of all 3 since 2007:

mosley - collazo win , cotto loss , margarito win
mayweather - hatton win , marquez win
pacquiao - delahoya win , cotto win , clottey win

even if you don't want to count delahoya , pacquiao still comes out on top.

Pac beating those 3 still dont mean he gets ranked the best over Mosley who Marg who beat Cotto.

[Frank Martin]

To be the best, you have to beat the best. Yes Cotto beat Shane but he beat Margarito who beat Cotto so he is the best WW until Manny or Floyd beats him.

[Left Banned Tua]

Pac beating those 3 still dont mean he gets ranked the best over Mosley who Marg who beat Cotto.

mosley lost to cotto who pacquiao beat.

clottey gave marg a tough fight who pacquiao beat easily.



mosley started fighting at 147 again in 2007.

he had 3 fights , 2 wins and a loss. collazo , cotto and margarito.

pacquiao in 4 months just fought cotto and clottey.

it's close but i give pacquiao the edge.

[Left Banned Tua]

To be the best, you have to beat the best. Yes Cotto beat Shane but he beat Margarito who beat Cotto so he is the best WW until Manny or Floyd beats him.

pacquiao who beat cotto who beat shane works just as well as your shane beat marg who beat cotto.