Top 10 Boxers Of All Time (Pound for Pound)

[Hannibal Barca]

as soon as i saw number 6...i was like...

how can anyone in their right mind put de la hoya above roy?.. let alone joe louis, Chavez and Hagler.......

Don't get me wrong , Oscar was one of my favorites.. but come on dog...

and then your number 1....imma floyd fan at heart.. but i'll put him there after he beats manny

roy isnt top ten either..neither is hagler.

Floyd will never be #1, and at this point, it's a stretch that he'll crack the top 20.

[illmatickid]

Floyd will never be #1, and at this point, it's a stretch that he'll crack the top 20.

fair enough....i can understand that.. but not even crack top 20? with a win over manny and maybe mosley too? what else would you like for him to do to get in there?

[Hannibal Barca]

fair enough....i can understand that.. but not even crack top 20? with a win over manny and maybe mosley too? what else would you like for him to do to get in there?

If he fights and dominates Mosely? Top 25. Mosely and Pac? Top 20. That is if Pac isn't on PED's, which at this point I think he is.

[JAB5239]

fair enough....i can understand that.. but not even crack top 20? with a win over manny and maybe mosley too? what else would you like for him to do to get in there?

Modern fighters are simply at a disadvantage because they fight so much less often. When you pick and choose your fights instead of just cleaning out divisions it becomes even more difficult to get ranked higher all time in my opinion.

[illmatickid]

If he fights and dominates Mosely? Top 25. Mosely and Pac? Top 20. That is if Pac isn't on PED's, which at this point I think he is.

thats what im talking bout...

[JAB5239]

If he fights and dominates Mosely? Top 25. Mosely and Pac? Top 20. That is if Pac isn't on PED's, which at this point I think he is.

With all due respect, it sounds like you're just saying this because you want it to happen. Who are you going to take out of the top 20 if Floyd beats Pac and Shane, and why?

[wazaa.]

10. Marvin Hagler

9. Julio Cesar Chavez

8. Roy Jones Jr

7. Joe Louis

6. Oscar De La Hoya

5. Sugar Ray Lenoard

4. Manny Pac

3. Sugar Ray Robinson

2. Muhammad Ali

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr

[IMG]http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_26QvuO0h1iU/R592P7Xm3BI/AAAAAAAAARc/hW4npP0n-CY/s400/******s.jpg[/IMG]

[carts]

i totally agree on this list specially number 1!!










defensive boxer!!

[jrosales13]

my top 10

1. SRR
2. Armstrong
3. Greb
4. B. Leonard
5. Pep
6. Ali
7. Langford
8. Gans
9. Ross
10. Charles

I know some people don't like HWs on a P4P list but to me that is not fair to HWs who I think P4P could beat some ATG fighters who fought in multiple weight-class...

And, I know some might think that is blasphemy that Ali is not in the top 5. But, I believe that I am actually giving him a compliment. I think you can make a case for him to be even lower IMO.

[jrosales13]

i totally agree on this list specially number 1!!










defensive boxer!!

Not even. I can't even put him ahead of Whitaker, Locche, or Pep as defense is concered. I do think he is in the top 5. But, those hold the top 3 spot IMO.