Top 10 Boxers Of All Time (Pound for Pound)

[wazaa.]

my top 10

1. SRR
2. Armstrong
3. Greb
4. B. Leonard
5. Pep
6. Ali
7. Langford
8. Gans
9. Ross
10. Charles

I know some people don't like HWs on a P4P list but to me that is not fair to HWs who I think P4P could beat some ATG fighters who fought in multiple weight-class...

And, I know some might think that is blasphemy that Ali is not in the top 5. But, I believe that I am actually giving him a compliment. I think you can make a case for him to be even lower IMO.

plz explain

[carts]

Not even. I can't even put him ahead of Whitaker, Locche, or Pep as defense is concered. I do think he is in the top 5. But, those hold the top 3 spot IMO.

i mean on that list he posted..

[jrosales13]

plz explain

Explain what? That a case can be made for fighters like Barney Ross, Langford, Joe Gans to be higher than Ali?

[jrosales13]

i mean on that list he posted..

Oh gotcha

[Hannibal Barca]

my top 10

1. SRR
2. Armstrong
3. Greb
4. B. Leonard
5. Pep
6. Ali
7. Langford
8. Gans
9. Ross
10. Charles

I know some people don't like HWs on a P4P list but to me that is not fair to HWs who I think P4P could beat some ATG fighters who fought in multiple weight-class...

And, I know some might think that is blasphemy that Ali is not in the top 5. But, I believe that I am actually giving him a compliment. I think you can make a case for him to be even lower IMO.

Ali at 6? Wow...

[ManniePhresh]

Not even. I can't even put him ahead of Whitaker, Locche, or Pep as defense is concered. I do think he is in the top 5. But, those hold the top 3 spot IMO.

no pacquiao?

[jrosales13]

Ali at 6? Wow...

Yes sir, Ali fought in the golden era of HW, That is why I have him ahead of Langofrd, Gans, Ross, Charles, etc etc...

But, IMO the 5 fighters I have was just amazing that I personally can not put Ali ahead of them.

[jrosales13]

no pacquiao?

For what defesne? Why would I put Pac in the top 5 in defense? I am not on fighters ****s like some "fans" are.

However, I think Pac is the greatest Filipino fighters of all time, I think he is the greatest Asian fighter of all time, and I think he is clearly in the top 3 greatest southpaw of all time...

[duasto]

This thread is amazing ... I've never see a thread that unite pac fans and floyd fans against the TS. Yeoh TS you should be proud of yourself for making us unite.


BTW, your ranking pathetic

[ManniePhresh]

i was just ****in with u.