Who has the better resume - Calzaghe or Mayweather Jr

[Easy-E]

Calzaghe has other fairly good wins like Bika, Reid, Woodhall, Viet, Mitchell and Brewer.

Compare those
"good wins" to Floyds good wins. It is not even close.

[boxasmash]

I agree that Ward is a very good fighter, but at the end of the day many Calzaghe fans were picking Kessler to KO him. And that is still regarded as one of Joe's best wins. Also Ward did it much easier.

Cotto beat Judah easier, Pac beat ODLH and Hatton easier.

[Easy-E]

Cotto beat Judah easier, Pac beat ODLH and Hatton easier.

Yeah but after Floyd beat them. Right after Floyd beat them. Kessler had some time to recover, but beating a fighter after is less impressive than beating them first.

[BEEHOP]

How does fighting and old blown up lightweight make floyds resume any better? and his wins over hatton and delahoya mean nothing too after what pac did to them.

WW Marquez is much better than any of Joe's wins (Hopkins excluded)

[-Spinal-]

good post man....

Lol Ice Cream was being sarcastic

[Number One]

WW Marquez is much better than any of Joe's wins (Hopkins excluded)

that is funny... a blown up piss drinking jmm is not better then any wins on joes resume... kessler is a better win then a fat jmm...

[catalinul]

Mayweather by significant margin.

[General Zod]

Mayweather and its not even close.Joes best wins are: past prime Eubank, Shot Roy, past prime Hopkins, Lacy and Kessler

[hammerhiem]

Floyd based on his 135 and below resume, also the likes of Hatton and JMM while lower weight fighters where both top 10 p4p.

[Biolink]

Beating a Shot(Roy Jones), Old(Hopkins), and 1 good opponent(Kessler)

Propels Calzaghe's legacy above Mayweather who actually beat people who were in their prime(Castillo, Hatton, Corrales). Where the hell is the logic?

P4P?!!!!

because there's honestly no contest in the resume's right now, and Mayweather's resume is only going to get better after he touches gloves with Mosley, Pacquiao, and potentially whomever is available at Welter Weight, be it an Andre Berto, potentiall Paul Williams. Or maybe even an Amir Khan and Saul Alvarez down the line.

And I gotta slightly apologize for talking about FANTASY fights, but its lunacy to compare a retired fighters resume to an active fighters resume, when the retired fighters resume wasn't even better prior to retiring.