Who has the better resume - Calzaghe or Mayweather Jr

[Easy-E]

Joe fought kessler while kessler was in his prime.... joe>>mayweather

explain how Joe's resume is better.
Mayweather fought prime Corrales and Castillo in their primes, both of whom are better fighters than Kessler.

[boxasmash]

Corrales, Castillo 2x, Hatton, De La Hoya, Judah, Chavez, and soon Mosley(at 32).



Eubank?, Lacy, Kessler, Hopkins, Jones(at 36).

Pretty close, Mayweather has a few more names though. I voted Calzaghe because I know Mayweather fans will come in here hating on Joe when in reality Mayweather hasn't done much more.

[Sweet Jesus]

Calzaghe has one of the greatest resumes of all time. Eubank, Hopkins, Jones. I'd like to see any fighter in history challenge that.

[Number One]

uhhh...no he could not have. p4p is not solely an American ranking system, and pre Golden Boy purchase I do not think it was biased.

What victories did he have that would make him even top 10 p4p when RJJ was p4p #1?

skills wise Joe could have been number 1 p4p... also he fought kessler then hopkins and then jones JR.. he deserves alot of props for fighting those 3 dangerous fighters in a row....

[-Spinal-]

Mayweather, and it's not even close.

Joe C was NEVER rated P4P 1, Floyd has, and soon will be again.

Fighting bums at 168 then moving up and beating old men, doesn't make a great resume. And the Kessler argument goes out the window after Ward brutalized him.


MAYWEATHER>>JOE

I disagree with that. Kessler is a good boxer and a good name on anyone's resume, he was just beaten by another good boxer in Ward. Being beaten by Ward is not shameful at all.

[Number One]

explain how Joe's resume is better.
Mayweather fought prime Corrales and Castillo in their primes, both of whom are better fighters than Kessler.

kessler in his prime was so much better than corrales.. rip corrales, but he was not on kesslers level...

[Number One]

Calzaghe has one of the greatest resumes of all time. Eubank, Hopkins, Jones. I'd like to see any fighter in history challenge that.

good post man....

[-Spinal-]

Pretty close, Mayweather has a few more names though. I voted Calzaghe because I know Mayweather fans will come in here hating on Joe when in reality Mayweather hasn't done much more.

I don't think it's close to be completely honest. Look at the age difference. Surely, Floyd will fight 2-3 more career enhancing opponents before 36.

[boxasmash]

Mayweather, and it's not even close.

Joe C was NEVER rated P4P 1, Floyd has, and soon will be again.

Fighting bums at 168 then moving up and beating old men, doesn't make a great resume. And the Kessler argument goes out the window after Ward brutalized him.


MAYWEATHER>>JOE

In that case, Judah, ODLH, Castillo,Corrales,Hatton and Chavez don't count as they all lost after they fought Floyd.

[S.G.]

i think its obvious that calzaghe has the better resume.... with wins over lacy, hopkins, jones JR, kessler, eubank.. those are better wins then mayweathers wins over judah, baldomir, de la hoya, marquez and a hatton that was moving up in weight because floyd was too scared to fight him at 140....

You've got to be a troll or a 13 year old girl. N-Dubz? Seriously?