Who has the better resume - Calzaghe or Mayweather Jr

[Number One]

i think its obvious that calzaghe has the better resume.... with wins over lacy, hopkins, jones JR, kessler, eubank.. those are better wins then mayweathers wins over judah, baldomir, de la hoya, marquez and a hatton that was moving up in weight because floyd was too scared to fight him at 140....

[BEEHOP]

Mayweather, and it's not even close.

Joe C was NEVER rated P4P 1, Floyd has, and soon will be again.

Fighting bums at 168 then moving up and beating old men, doesn't make a great resume. And the Kessler argument goes out the window after Ward brutalized him.


MAYWEATHER>>JOE

[Smokin'J]

Carl the Cobra beats them both.

[Number One]

Mayweather, and it's not even close.

Joe C was NEVER rated P4P 1, Floyd has and soon will be again.

to be fair.. that was because many americans hated Joe.... they were biased... Joe could easily have been p4p #1 after wins over jones JR and hopkins...

[Easy-E]

May Jr by far.

[Brooklyn Rican]

Mayweather has Castillo, Gatti, Corrales, Zab, Corley, Marquez, De La Hoya, Hatton and soon to have mosley on his resume win or lose...he has a better resume then calzaghe ever will

[Chups]

Both have 2 HOF on their resumes. Roy Jones and Delahoya were already washed up when they got to them. But a Bernard win is better than a bloated Juan Manuel Marquez.

[Number One]

Mayweather, and it's not even close.

Joe C was NEVER rated P4P 1, Floyd has, and soon will be again.

Fighting bums at 168 then moving up and beating old men, doesn't make a great resume. And the Kessler argument goes out the window after Ward brutalized him.


MAYWEATHER>>JOE

Joe fought kessler while kessler was in his prime.... joe>>mayweather

[Easy-E]

to be fair.. that was because many americans hated Joe.... they were biased... Joe could easily have been p4p #1 after wins over jones JR and hopkins...

uhhh...no he could not have. p4p is not solely an American ranking system, and pre Golden Boy purchase I do not think it was biased.

What victories did he have that would make him even top 10 p4p when RJJ was p4p #1?

[-Spinal-]

Corrales, Castillo 2x, Hatton, De La Hoya, Judah, Chavez, and soon Mosley(at 32).



Eubank?, Lacy, Kessler, Hopkins, Jones(at 36).